| Course | BUS 225 Legal Environment of Business |
|---|---|
| Module | Module 3 |
| Paper type | Contract analysis |
| Length | About 1,086 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Aspen University |
| Program | Business Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS 225 Module 3
Forty Kayaks at $410: Formation, Breach and Damages in an Emailed Wholesale Order
Student Name
Business Administration Program, Aspen University
BUS 225: Legal Environment of Business
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Forty Kayaks at $410: Formation, Breach and Damages in an Emailed Wholesale Order
In January, Pinecrest's buyer emailed a Colorado kayak maker asking for a price on 40 touring kayaks for May delivery. The maker's sales manager replied with a quote of $410 per kayak, delivered, valid for fourteen days. Nine days later Pinecrest replied, "We'll take 40 at $410, delivery by May 1." The maker sent back an order acknowledgment confirming quantity, price and date, which added a clause requiring arbitration of disputes and a clause limiting the maker's liability to replacement of defective boats. In March, after a resin shortage raised its costs, the maker wrote that it could deliver only at $480 per kayak. Pinecrest refused, bought 40 comparable kayaks elsewhere at $468 and now wants to know whether it had a contract and what it can recover.
Which Law Applies
Contracts for the sale of goods, meaning movable things, are governed by Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code, which Colorado has adopted; contracts for services and real estate remain under the common law (Legal Information Institute, n.d.). Kayaks are goods, and both parties are merchants who deal in them, so Article 2 applies, including several rules written specifically for transactions between merchants. Where the code is silent, general contract principles fill the gaps.
Was There a Contract?
Contract formation is judged objectively, by what a reasonable person would understand from the parties' words and conduct, not by what either party privately intended. A Virginia court enforced a land sale written on a restaurant check even though the seller later said he had been joking, because his words and conduct reasonably appeared serious (Lucy v. Zehmer, 1954). Under that standard, the maker's email was an offer: it stated a quantity, price, delivery term and deadline, and invited acceptance. Pinecrest accepted within the fourteen days with language that matched the offer. Email is a valid means of offer and acceptance, and nothing in the exchange suggested either side intended to wait for a formal signed document. A contract for 40 kayaks at $410 was formed on the day Pinecrest replied.
The Writing Requirement
For sales of goods priced at $500 or more, Article 2 requires a writing signed by the party that is now resisting the contract, although the writing need only indicate that a contract was made and state a quantity (Legal Information Institute, n.d.). The order is worth $16,400. The maker's own email quote, sent from its sales manager's account with his name in the signature block, and its later order acknowledgment both indicate a contract and state the quantity. Federal and state electronic signature laws treat such electronic records and signatures as satisfying writing requirements, so the maker cannot escape the contract on this ground.
The Added Terms
The acknowledgment added arbitration and a limit on liability. Under the code's rule for conflicting forms, a clear expression of acceptance still counts as one even when it proposes extra terms, and between merchants the extra terms are treated as added to the deal except where the offer limited acceptance to its own terms, the new terms materially alter the bargain, or the other party objects in time (Legal Information Institute, n.d.). But here the acknowledgment came after the contract was already formed by Pinecrest's email, so it was a proposal to add terms to an existing deal rather than an acceptance. Pinecrest never agreed to those terms. A limit on the maker's liability would also likely be treated as a material alteration. Neither added clause controls the dispute over late delivery.
Breach and Pinecrest's Response
The maker's March email stating it would deliver only at a higher price was a clear refusal to perform the contract as agreed, a repudiation made before performance was due. Pinecrest was entitled to treat the contract as broken and seek another source rather than wait until May. A higher cost of materials does not usually excuse a seller; excuse under the code is limited to failures caused by contingencies whose non-occurrence was a basic assumption of the contract, and ordinary price increases are the kind of risk a fixed-price seller accepts. Pinecrest acted promptly and reasonably by buying substitute kayaks within two weeks from an established supplier.
Measuring the Damages
A buyer who reasonably covers can recover the difference between the cost of cover and the contract price, plus incidental and consequential damages, less expenses saved (Legal Information Institute, n.d.). Consequential damages are limited to losses the breaching party had reason to foresee when the contract was made, a principle the English Court of Exchequer set out long ago and American courts still follow (Hadley v. Baxendale, 1854). Pinecrest's figures are below.
| Item | Amount | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Cover price, 40 kayaks at $468 | $18,720 | Substitute purchase |
| Contract price, 40 kayaks at $410 | $16,400 | Emailed agreement |
| Difference | $2,320 | Cover minus contract price |
| Incidental: freight not included in cover quote | $260 | Invoice from carrier |
| Total recoverable | $2,580 | Before any consequential losses |
Consequential Losses
Pinecrest also lost a planned early-May kayak clinic because the replacement boats arrived on May 9, and it estimates $1,100 in clinic fees and related sales. Whether that is recoverable depends on foreseeability. The maker knew the boats were for retail sale in May, but nothing shows it knew about the clinic. A court would likely allow the difference in cost and incidental freight but treat the clinic losses as too remote unless Pinecrest can show the maker was told. The lesson for future orders is to state important downstream uses in the purchase order.
Lessons for Future Orders
The dispute points to simple improvements. Pinecrest's purchase orders should state that acceptance is limited to their terms and that added terms in the seller's forms are rejected. Orders placed by email should attach Pinecrest's standard terms. Where a delivery date supports a planned event, the order should say so, which makes related losses foreseeable. And for goods with volatile input costs, Pinecrest may agree to a price adjustment clause in exchange for a firm delivery commitment.
Conclusion
The emailed exchange formed a contract for a sale of goods under Article 2, satisfied the writing requirement and was not changed by terms the maker added later. The maker's refusal to deliver at the agreed price was a repudiation not excused by higher costs. Pinecrest's prompt cover entitles it to about $2,580, and more only if it can show the maker foresaw the clinic losses. Pinecrest should send a written demand for that amount before considering further action.
References
Hadley v. Baxendale, 9 Ex. 341, 156 Eng. Rep. 145 (1854).
Legal Information Institute. (n.d.). U.C.C. Article 2: Sales. Cornell Law School. https://www.law.cornell.edu/ucc/2
Lucy v. Zehmer, 196 Va. 493, 84 S.E.2d 516 (1954).
BUS 225 Module 3 instructions, in plain terms
Contracts appear in Aspen's catalog description of BUS 225, and the third module typically asks for an analysis of formation and breach. The exact Module 3 prompt is inside your course, so this example applies the rules to one sale. Identify whether the deal involves goods or services, since that decides which law applies. Test formation step by step: offer, acceptance and the parties' objective intent. Check any writing requirement. Deal with conflicting terms in business forms carefully, noting when a contract was formed. Identify the breach and whether any excuse applies. Calculate damages with a clear method and show the figures. Explain any limit on recovery, especially foreseeability for consequential losses.
How this BUS 225 Module 3 example is built
The paper opens with the email quote, the acceptance nine days later, the acknowledgment form and the maker's demand for $480 per boat. It explains that kayaks are goods and both parties are merchants. Applying the objective test, it finds the quote was an offer accepted by email. The writing section shows the maker's own emails satisfy the $500 rule. The added arbitration and liability terms are analyzed under the rule for conflicting forms and found not to bind Pinecrest. The breach section treats the demand as a repudiation not excused by higher costs. A table sets out the $18,720 cover cost, the $16,400 contract price, $260 freight and a $2,580 total. Foreseeability of the lost clinic and lessons for future orders close the analysis.
Reading the BUS 225 Module 3 grading rubric
Contract analyses are assessed on correct choice of law, careful application of each element, accurate damages and attention to limits. This example identifies Article 2, applies formation rules to the actual email wording and shows why the acknowledgment came too late to change the deal. The APA reference list holds Lucy v. Zehmer on objective intent, Hadley v. Baxendale on foreseeable damages and Cornell's Legal Information Institute text of Article 2. The worked table lets an instructor check the arithmetic. Declining to claim the clinic losses without proof of foreseeability shows the judgment courts apply. Closing with changes to purchase orders connects the law to management practice.
BUS 225 Module 3 help: mistakes that cost marks
A frequent mistake is reaching for general contract doctrine when the deal is for goods. Settle which body of law controls before anything else. Another is treating any later document as part of the contract; ask when the contract was formed. Show your damages calculation, not only the total, and state where each number comes from. Explain why a cost increase does or does not excuse performance. Don't claim every loss; consider foreseeability. Cite the Uniform Commercial Code through a reliable source such as Cornell's text. Keep the analysis in order, element by element, so the reader can follow each conclusion back to the rule that produced it. If the battle-of-the-forms rule seems tangled, a tutor can diagram an exchange of forms with you step by step.
Write yours, or have the desk draft it
This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.
More BUS 225 and Business Administration sample papers
- BUS 225 Module 1: Courts and Jurisdiction
- BUS 225 Module 2: Litigation and ADR
- BUS 225 Module 4: Intellectual Property Plan
- BUS 225 Module 5: Business Crime and Liability
- BUS 225 Module 6: Agency and Employment
- BUS 225 Module 7: Discrimination and Fair Employment
- BUS 225 Module 8: Consumer Protection and Securities
- BUS 210 Module 5: Human Resources Plan
- BUS 320 Module 5: Pricing Decisions
- COM 220 Module 8: Persuasive Proposals
- MGT 215 Module 6: Service Recovery and Complaints
BUS 225 Module 3 questions, answered
What does BUS 225 Module 3 usually ask for?
Aspen's BUS 225 includes contract law, so a paper analyzing whether a contract was formed, whether it was breached and what damages follow is typical. Follow your classroom prompt.
Does the UCC apply to all contracts?
No. Article 2 governs sales of goods; contracts for services and real estate are governed mainly by the common law.
What are cover damages?
When a seller fails to deliver, the buyer may buy substitute goods and recover the difference between that cost and the contract price, plus incidental damages.
Where can I find a free BUS 225 Module 3 sample paper?
This page holds the full contract analysis above, following an emailed kayak order from formation through breach and a worked table of cover damages.
Does an email count as a signed writing for a contract?
Generally yes; federal and state electronic signature laws let electronic records and signatures satisfy writing requirements such as the UCC's rule for sales of $500 or more.