| Course | DNP845 Theoretical and Scientific Underpinnings |
|---|---|
| Module | Module 3 |
| Paper type | Theory comparison paper |
| Length | About 1,094 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Aspen University |
| Program | DNP |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DNP845 Module 3
A Wide Lens and a Close One: Comparing Orem's Self-Care Deficit Theory and Riegel's Middle-Range Self-Care Theory for Heart Failure in Home Health
Student Name
Doctor of Nursing Practice Program, Aspen University
DNP845: Theoretical and Scientific Underpinnings
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
A Wide Lens and a Close One: Comparing Orem's Self-Care Deficit Theory and Riegel's Middle-Range Self-Care Theory for Heart Failure in Home Health
Nursing theories differ in scope. Grand theories offer broad perspectives on nursing and the person, while middle-range theories address a narrower set of concepts closer to practice and more easily tested. This paper compares one grand theory, Orem's self-care deficit theory, with one middle-range theory, the theory of self-care of chronic illness, for a single clinical problem: frequent readmissions among home health patients with heart failure. It argues that the middle-range theory provides more direct guidance for a DNP project, while the grand theory remains useful for defining the nurse's role.
The Clinical Problem
A composite home health agency serves about 220 patients with heart failure each year. Its 30-day rehospitalization rate for these patients is 24 percent, and chart reviews suggest that many readmissions follow days of unrecognized weight gain and worsening breathlessness, missed diuretic doses, or high-sodium meals. Nurses teach each patient, yet the same patterns recur. The DNP student wants a theory that explains why teaching does not translate into daily self-care and that points to measurable interventions.
Orem's Self-Care Deficit Theory
At the center of Orem's grand theory is self-care: deliberate activity adults undertake for themselves to sustain life, health, and well-being. The theory calls a person's ability to carry out that activity self-care agency, and it locates the need for nursing at the point where that ability falls short of what the person's situation requires (Orem, 2001). Self-care requisites are universal, developmental, or related to health deviations such as chronic illness. When a deficit exists, the nurse designs a nursing system that is wholly compensatory, partly compensatory, or supportive-educative.
Applied to heart failure, the theory identifies health deviation requisites such as daily weighing, fluid and sodium management, and medication adherence, and it suggests that a patient who does not perform these actions has a self-care deficit. It then directs the nurse to a supportive-educative system for patients who are able but need knowledge and encouragement, or a partly compensatory system, such as a family member preparing medications, for those with physical or cognitive limits. Its strength is a clear account of when and why nursing is needed. Its limitation for this problem is abstraction: it does not specify which components of heart failure self-care fail or which factors explain the failure.
Riegel's Middle-Range Self-Care Theory
Riegel et al. (2012) proposed a middle-range theory describing self-care in chronic illness as a process of maintaining health through health-promoting practices and managing illness. It has three core concepts: self-care maintenance, behaviors that maintain physical and emotional stability, such as taking medications and following a diet; self-care monitoring, observing oneself for changes in signs and symptoms; and self-care management, responding to those changes when they occur, such as taking an extra diuretic dose or calling the nurse. The theory also names factors that influence self-care, including experience and skill, motivation, cultural beliefs and values, confidence, habits, functional and cognitive abilities, support from others, and access to care.
For heart failure, the theory explains the agency's pattern precisely. Patients may be performing maintenance, taking most medications, while failing at monitoring, not weighing daily or not recognizing that a two-pound gain matters, and at management, not knowing what to do when symptoms worsen. Teaching that focuses on what to take and what to avoid addresses maintenance, but readmissions follow failures of monitoring and management, which require a different kind of intervention. The theory also points to measurement: the Self-Care of Heart Failure Index measures maintenance, management, and confidence and has been revised and tested in heart failure populations (Riegel et al., 2009).
Comparing the Two
The theories differ in scope, level of abstraction, and testability. Orem's theory explains the purpose of nursing and when it is needed across all populations; the middle-range theory explains a specific process in chronic illness. Orem's concepts, such as self-care agency, are broad and difficult to measure directly; the middle-range theory's concepts have been operationalized in validated instruments. Orem's theory guides the design of nursing systems; the middle-range theory guides the design of specific interventions, such as teaching patients to interpret daily weights and giving them a written action plan for symptom changes.
The theories are also compatible. The middle-range theory builds on the idea of self-care that Orem placed at the center of nursing, and a DNP project can use Orem to define the nurse's role and the middle-range theory to design and evaluate the intervention.
Implications for the DNP Project
Guided by the middle-range theory, the DNP student would assess each patient's maintenance, monitoring, and management using the Self-Care of Heart Failure Index at admission to home health; provide scales and teach symptom monitoring with teach-back; give each patient a color-coded action plan specifying what to do for weight gain or increased breathlessness; and use telephone check-ins to coach management decisions. Influencing factors from the theory would shape tailoring: patients with low confidence would receive more coaching, and those with cognitive limits would have a caregiver included, which is where Orem's partly compensatory system becomes relevant. Outcomes would include self-care index scores at 30 and 60 days and the 30-day rehospitalization rate.
A Critique of the Middle-Range Theory
The middle-range theory is not without weaknesses. Its list of influencing factors is long, and it does not specify how they interact or which matter most for a given patient, so the DNP student must still use judgment in tailoring. It focuses on the individual and names access to care as a factor without explaining how social conditions such as food insecurity or unstable housing shape monitoring and management; a patient who cannot afford low-sodium foods is not failing at self-care maintenance in the same way as one who does not know which foods to avoid. And the theory's instruments rely on self-report, which may overstate adherence. The project can address these limits by adding a brief social needs screen at admission and by pairing self-report with objective data, such as transmitted daily weights, where available.
Conclusion
Orem's self-care deficit theory offers a wide lens that explains why nursing is needed when patients cannot meet their self-care demands. Riegel's middle-range self-care theory offers a close lens that explains which parts of heart failure self-care break down and what influences them, with instruments to measure change. For a DNP project aimed at reducing readmissions, the middle-range theory provides the more direct guide, while Orem's theory frames the nurse's role in compensating for deficits the patient cannot overcome alone.
References
Orem, D. E. (2001). Nursing: Concepts of practice (6th ed.). Mosby.
Riegel, B., Jaarsma, T., & Strömberg, A. (2012). A middle-range theory of self-care of chronic illness. Advances in Nursing Science, 35(3), 194-204. https://doi.org/10.1097/ANS.0b013e318261b1ba
Riegel, B., Lee, C. S., Dickson, V. V., & Carlson, B. (2009). An update on the Self-Care of Heart Failure Index. Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing, 24(6), 485-497. https://doi.org/10.1097/JCN.0b013e3181b4baa0
What the DNP845 Module 3 instructions ask for
Module 3 in Aspen's DNP845 usually has you hold a broad and a narrower theory up to the same clinical problem and pick the one that would steer a project better. Describe the clinical problem with local data. Explain each theory from its primary source. Apply each to the problem. Compare them on scope, abstraction, testability and usefulness. Explain how they relate. Show how the chosen theory shapes assessment, intervention and measurement in a project. Critique the chosen theory. Use the theories' own measurement tools where they exist, since a middle-range theory's measures are often its practical advantage.
Inside the DNP845 Module 3 example
The introduction states that nursing theories differ in scope. The problem section describes the agency's heart failure patients and readmissions after weight gain went unnoticed. The Orem section explains self-care, self-care deficits and nursing systems, and how the theory frames heart failure as demands exceeding ability. The Riegel section explains maintenance, monitoring and management and why the theory explains the agency's pattern precisely: patients maintain routines but miss symptom changes. The comparison section contrasts breadth with precision and abstraction with testability, then shows the theories fit together. The project section uses the Self-Care of Heart Failure Index at admission, targets monitoring with daily weights and teaching, and measures change. The critique names weaknesses such as limited attention to caregivers.
Reading the DNP845 Module 3 grading rubric
Theory comparison papers in DNP845 get credit for accurate theories, application to the same problem, a structured comparison, a reasoned choice and critique. Both theories come from primary sources. The comparison uses explicit dimensions rather than impressions. The project section shows how the chosen theory changes what nurses assess and measure. The critique is specific. The sources are Orem's sixth edition from 2001, the 2012 middle-range theory paper by Riegel, Jaarsma and Strömberg, and Riegel's development of the Self-Care of Heart Failure Index. The ending keeps both theories in view, the wide lens and the close one, as the title promises.
DNP845 Module 3 help: mistakes that cost marks
Comparison papers often describe two theories separately and compare them in one paragraph. Compare throughout. Another gap is choosing a theory without showing how it changes the project. Name assessments and measures. Students also skip critique of the chosen theory. Include it. Use primary sources. Keep the agency composite and its data plausible. Explain how the theories relate, not only how they differ. Use the theory's own instrument if one exists. Finally, connect the choice to a measurable outcome, such as readmissions, since a DNP project must show results. Show the index's three scales in a sentence each, so the reader sees why it fits the problem. Include caregivers, since many heart failure patients rely on them for monitoring. Report the agency's readmission figure as your baseline. Show how each theory would change one specific nursing action for the chosen problem.
Write yours, or have the desk draft it
This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.
More DNP845 and DNP sample papers
- DNP845 Module 1: Ways of Knowing
- DNP845 Module 2: Philosophy of Science
- DNP845 Module 4: Theory Selection
- DNP845 Module 5: Theory Concept Mapping
- DNP845 Module 6: Borrowed Theory Discussion
- DNP845 Module 7: Translation Science
- DNP845 Module 8: Disseminating Findings
- DNP855 Module 4: Clinical Microsystem Analysis
- DNP885 Module 4: Variance Analysis Paper
- DNP 830 Module 7: Ethics and Collaboration in Global Health
- DNP 805 Module 1: Leadership Competencies for System Change
DNP845 Module 3 questions, answered
What does DNP845 Module 3 usually ask for?
The module often asks you to compare a grand theory and a middle-range theory for one clinical problem and judge which better guides practice or a DNP project. Aspen does not publish module deliverables, so your classroom's instructions govern.
What is the difference between grand and middle-range theory?
Grand theories offer broad, abstract perspectives on nursing and the person across all settings. Middle-range theories address a narrower set of concrete concepts closer to practice, which makes them easier to test and to use in designing interventions.
What are the three concepts of the theory of self-care of chronic illness?
Self-care maintenance, behaviors that keep a person stable; self-care monitoring, watching for changes in signs and symptoms; and self-care management, responding to those changes when they occur.
Where can I find a free DNP845 Module 3 sample paper?
The full DNP845 Module 3 paper is above, comparing Orem's grand theory and Riegel's middle-range self-care theory for heart failure in home health.
Which theory wins in the DNP845 Module 3 comparison?
Riegel's middle-range theory, because it explains the agency's exact pattern: patients keep routines but miss weight changes. Orem's theory still frames the broader view of self-care demand.