| Course | DNP850 Nursing Practice, Professionalism, and Scholarship |
|---|---|
| Module | Module 5 |
| Paper type | Ethics analysis |
| Length | About 1,045 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Aspen University |
| Program | DNP |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DNP850 Module 5
No One to Ask: An Ethics Analysis of Treatment Decisions for an Unrepresented Older Adult on a Medical Unit
Student Name
Doctor of Nursing Practice Program, Aspen University
DNP850: Nursing Practice, Professionalism, and Scholarship
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
No One to Ask: An Ethics Analysis of Treatment Decisions for an Unrepresented Older Adult on a Medical Unit
Most ethical discussions about end-of-life decisions assume that someone can speak for the patient: the patient, an advance directive, or a surrogate. For some older adults, none exists. This paper analyzes one such situation from a composite hospital medical unit, identifies the ethical principles and professional obligations at stake, applies a published professional position on decision-making for these patients, and proposes a process for the hospital.
The Situation
Mr. E., 79, has advanced dementia and has been a long-stay nursing home resident for six years. He has no spouse, children, or known relatives, no advance directive, and no guardian. He has been admitted four times in the past year with aspiration pneumonia. He cannot state preferences, but nursing home staff describe him as a man who enjoyed music and disliked being restrained. On this admission, he is full code by default. Night physicians have twice discussed whether to transfer him to intensive care; one ordered it, and another, a week later, decided against it for a similar episode. A nurse noted that his code status seemed to depend on who was on call.
The Ethical Problem
The American Geriatrics Society defines unbefriended older adults as patients who lack capacity to make the medical decision at hand, have no advance directive that addresses it and cannot make one, and lack family, friends, or a legally authorized surrogate (Farrell et al., 2017). Mr. E. meets all three conditions. The ethical problem is not only which treatment to choose but who has the authority to choose and by what process. When no one speaks for the patient, the risk is not that the wrong person decides, but that decisions are made without anyone being accountable for them.
Principles in Tension
Autonomy cannot be exercised directly, but respect for persons still requires that decisions reflect what is known of Mr. E.'s values rather than defaults (Beauchamp & Childress, 2019). Beneficence and nonmaleficence require weighing the likely benefit of intensive care, mechanical ventilation, and resuscitation against their burdens for a man with advanced dementia and recurrent aspiration, whose underlying condition will not improve. Justice requires that unrepresented patients receive the same careful, consistent decision-making as those with families, and that they are neither overtreated because no one objects nor undertreated because no one advocates.
The current practice fails on justice most clearly. Leaving decisions to whichever physician is on call produces inconsistent care that depends on chance. Default full-code status may impose burdensome treatments that nobody who knew him would have chosen, while a unilateral decision to withhold treatment by one physician lacks transparency.
Professional Obligations
The Code of Ethics makes advocacy part of the nurse's basic duty, and that duty weighs more heavily when a patient has no voice of their own (American Nurses Association, 2015). Nurses are often the professionals who know unrepresented patients best, through daily care and conversations with nursing home staff. The nurse who noticed the inconsistency in Mr. E.'s care was exercising this obligation; the question is what the organization gives her to act on it.
A Fair Process
The AGS position statement recommends that decisions for unbefriended older adults follow standards of procedural fairness, including a capacity assessment, a diligent search for potential surrogates, including nontraditional ones such as close friends or long-time caregivers, and a team-based effort to determine the patient's preferences by synthesizing all available evidence (Farrell et al., 2017). It also calls for national efforts to reduce the number of unbefriended older adults through earlier advance care planning.
For Mr. E., this means documenting his lack of capacity; searching for surrogates, including asking nursing home staff whether any friend or long-time aide knew him well; gathering evidence of his values, such as his dislike of restraints and his enjoyment of music; and convening a team of the attending physician, nurse, social worker, chaplain, and a member of the ethics committee to recommend a plan of care. Given his recurrent aspiration and advanced dementia, the team might recommend a plan focused on comfort and treatment of reversible problems without intensive care or resuscitation, documented with its reasoning and reviewed if his condition changes.
Anticipating Objections
Some clinicians may object that a team review slows care. The process does not apply to emergencies, in which clinicians must act on their best judgment of the patient's interests, and a review scheduled within a day or two of admission prevents the emergency from arising unplanned. Others may argue that a court-appointed guardian is the proper decision-maker. Guardianship is sometimes appropriate, but it is slow, often assigns a stranger with no knowledge of the patient, and does not remove the need for clinicians to provide a clear recommendation. A third objection is that without a surrogate, choosing a comfort-focused plan risks devaluing a vulnerable patient's life. The answer is the process itself: a decision reached by a documented, multidisciplinary review of the patient's condition and known values is far less likely to reflect bias than a decision made at 3 a.m. by one physician, or a default of full treatment that no one chose.
Recommendations for the Organization
The hospital should adopt a policy for unrepresented patients that requires a team-based review, with ethics committee participation, before major decisions such as code status, intensive care admission, or surgery; prohibits single-physician decisions on these matters except in emergencies; requires documentation of the search for surrogates and of the evidence about the patient's values; and triggers a review whenever the patient's condition changes significantly. It should also work with local nursing homes to complete advance care planning with residents while they can still participate, which is the most effective way to prevent patients from becoming unrepresented.
Conclusion
Mr. E.'s care exposed an ethical gap: decisions made by chance for a man with no one to speak for him. Respect for the person, the duty to benefit him, fairness to unrepresented patients, the nurse's obligation to advocate, and a published professional position all point to the same remedy, a fair, team-based process that seeks his values, documents its reasoning, and holds the organization accountable. Building that process is an ethical responsibility that DNP-prepared nurses are well placed to lead.
References
American Nurses Association. (2015). Code of ethics for nurses with interpretive statements. Nursesbooks.org.
Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2019). Principles of biomedical ethics (8th ed.). Oxford University Press.
Farrell, T. W., Widera, E., Rosenberg, L., Rubin, C. D., Naik, A. D., Braun, U., Torke, A., Li, I., Vitale, C., Shega, J., & the Ethics, Clinical Practice and Models of Care, and Public Policy Committees of the American Geriatrics Society. (2017). AGS position statement: Making medical treatment decisions for unbefriended older adults. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 65(1), 14-15. https://doi.org/10.1111/jgs.14586
Reading the DNP850 Module 5 assignment instructions
Aspen's DNP850 Module 5 usually asks for an ethics analysis of a situation from your own setting, using principles, professional codes and published guidance. Choose a case with real ethical tension, not one with an obvious answer. Present the facts that matter, including what is known of the patient's values. Define the problem with a source, then set the principles in tension with one another instead of naming each in turn. Apply your professional code to the nurse's role. Recommend a process or decision and explain why it is fair. Anticipate objections and answer them. Finish with an organizational change that keeps the next unrepresented patient from depending on who happens to be on call. Keep the patient composite and the details clinically plausible, with nothing that could identify a real person or unit.
Inside the DNP850 Module 5 example
The introduction notes that most end-of-life ethics assumes someone can speak for the patient. The situation section describes Mr. E.: six years in long-term care, three admissions for aspiration and no one to call. The problem section uses the AGS position statement to classify him and recasts the issue as one of process. The principles section shows respect for persons through his known preferences, weighs beneficence against the burdens of intensive care and identifies justice as the principle current practice fails. The professional section applies the Code's advocacy duty. A fair-process section builds a team review step by step. The objections section answers concerns about delay, guardianship and devaluing his life, and recommendations follow for policy, training and prevention.
DNP850 Module 5 rubric: what earns full marks
Ethics analyses in DNP850 are graded on accurate case facts, a defined problem, principles applied rather than listed, professional obligations, a reasoned recommendation and attention to systems. This paper earns credit by naming justice, in the sense of consistent and fair treatment, as the failed principle. Beauchamp and Childress's eighth edition from 2019 supplies the principles. Farrell and colleagues' 2017 AGS position statement in the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society defines the population and the process. The ANA Code from 2015 frames the nurse's advocacy duty. Graders look for objections handled honestly, and this paper takes on three. The organizational recommendations show doctoral reach, since they prevent the next case rather than only resolving this one.
DNP850 Module 5 help from the desk
Ethics papers often recite four principles in four paragraphs without applying them. Weigh them against each other in the case. Another frequent gap is jumping to a decision, such as comfort care, without a fair process to reach it. Explain who decides and how. Students also skip what is known of the patient's values; even an unrepresented patient has a history. Use a published definition for the problem. Answer at least two objections. Keep the nurse's role visible, since the course is about professional practice. Add an organizational fix. Avoid suggesting that withholding treatment is automatic for older adults with dementia. Keep the case composite. Finally, cite the position statement accurately rather than paraphrasing it into rules it does not contain.
Write yours, or have the desk draft it
This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.
More DNP850 and DNP sample papers
- DNP850 Module 1: DNP Role Paper
- DNP850 Module 2: DNP Essentials Self-Assessment
- DNP850 Module 3: Practice Scholarship vs Research Paper
- DNP850 Module 4: Professional Accountability Discussion
- DNP850 Module 6: Mentorship Plan
- DNP850 Module 7: Manuscript Dissemination Plan
- DNP850 Module 8: Professional Identity Statement
- DNP 830 Module 1: Measuring Global Burden
- DNP 851A Module 4: Barriers and Small Tests of Change
- DNP 851B Module 8: Results Chapter With Tables and Figures
- DNP865 Module 3: Documentation Workflow Map
DNP850 Module 5 questions, answered
What does DNP850 Module 5 usually ask for?
The module often asks for an ethics analysis of a situation from your own practice setting, applying ethical principles, professional codes and relevant guidance. Aspen does not publish module deliverables, so your classroom's instructions govern.
Who is an unbefriended older adult?
The American Geriatrics Society defines unbefriended older adults as patients who lack capacity for the decision at hand, have no advance directive addressing it and cannot create one, and have no family, friends or legally authorized surrogate.
How should decisions be made for unrepresented patients?
Through a fair, team-based process that assesses capacity, searches for surrogates including nontraditional ones, gathers evidence of the patient's values and documents its reasoning, often with ethics committee participation, rather than leaving decisions to a single clinician.
Where can I find a free DNP850 Module 5 sample paper?
The full DNP850 Module 5 paper is above, analyzing treatment decisions for an unrepresented 79-year-old with dementia and aspiration whose care depended on who was on call.
Which ethical principle does the DNP850 Module 5 paper say is failing?
Justice, in the sense of fair and consistent treatment. Mr. E. received intensive care or not depending on the physician on call, so the paper proposes a team review to make decisions consistent.