DNP880 Module 4 IRB and QI Determination Example

Reviewed by Maren Hollowell, MSN, RN Aspen University Updated October 2026

This DNP880 Module 4 sample paper drafts what goes to the ethics board for the Maple Street food screening work, asking the university's IRB to determine that it is quality improvement. The fourth module of Aspen University's DNP Project course asks for IRB-facing documents. The submission summarizes the 16-week project for reviewers, then argues from the Hastings Center report by Lynn and colleagues that its purpose, design and risk make it improvement work. It keeps protections regardless, drawing on Emanuel's conditions for ethical research: a plain-language information sheet instead of signed consent, private questioning, a referral pathway for every positive screen and a de-identified data extract. Site approval, conflicts of interest and how SQUIRE 2.0 asks authors to report ethics complete it.

CourseDNP880 DNP Project
ModuleModule 4
Paper typeEthics review submission
LengthAbout 1,302 words, 7 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolAspen University
ProgramDNP
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DNP880 Module 4

1

Quality Improvement, Not Research, and Still Protected: The Ethics Review Submission for a Food Insecurity Screening Project

Student Name

Doctor of Nursing Practice Program, Aspen University

DNP880: DNP Project

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this page is doingThe title states the determination the submission requests and signals that protections remain in place either way, which is the position a review board expects a DNP student to take. APA 7 student title page for a doctoral program.
2

Quality Improvement, Not Research, and Still Protected: The Ethics Review Submission for a Food Insecurity Screening Project

Every DNP project that involves patients must pass through an ethics review, and the student must decide how to present it. This submission asks the university's institutional review board to determine that the Maple Street food insecurity screening and referral project is quality improvement, not human subjects research, and describes the protections the project will apply regardless of that determination: voluntary participation, privacy, minimal data, secure storage, and a pathway to help for every patient who screens positive.

What this page is doingThe introduction states what the submission asks for and commits to protections independent of the outcome, which reviewers look for.
3

Project Summary for Reviewers

Over 16 weeks, medical assistants at two clinics of a composite federally qualified health center will ask adults with type 2 diabetes two validated questions about food insecurity during rooming. Patients who answer affirmatively will be offered a same-visit meeting with a community health worker, who can complete an electronic referral to the regional food bank and will call two weeks later to confirm whether food was received. The DNP student will extract screening, referral, follow-up, visit length, and A1c data from the electronic record to evaluate the change using run charts. No experimental treatment is introduced, no patient is randomized, and no care is withheld.

What this page is doingA plain summary written for reviewers who do not know the site helps them judge the category quickly.
4

Why the Project Is Quality Improvement

A working group convened by the Hastings Center characterized improvement work as systematic, driven by data, and aimed at prompt gains in how one organization delivers care, and argued that most of it falls outside human subjects research and belongs under the ordinary supervision of clinical practice rather than board review (Lynn et al., 2007). The project fits that definition on each characteristic the group described. Its purpose is to improve care at Maple Street, not to produce generalizable knowledge. The intervention, screening and referral, reflects recommended practice rather than an unproven treatment. The changes are tested in iterative cycles and adjusted locally. The data are those the clinic would use to monitor its own performance. And the risks to patients are no greater than those of usual care.

The student intends to present results at a professional conference and in a DNP project repository. Dissemination alone does not convert quality improvement into research, but because institutions differ on this point, the student is requesting a formal determination rather than deciding the question alone. The student does not decide whether a project is research; the board does.

What this page is doingThe QI argument is built on a published framework applied point by point, and the highlighted sentence shows appropriate deference to the reviewing body.
5

The Protections the Project Keeps

Even if the board determines the project is not research, the ethical requirements for work involving patients still apply. Emanuel et al. (2000) argued that consent alone does not make a study ethical and set out seven conditions; among them are that the work have value, that it be sound in method, that participants be chosen fairly, that its benefits outweigh its risks, and that the people involved be treated with respect, including protection of their privacy and freedom to withdraw. Several translate directly to this project. Its value is clear: it addresses an unmet need in a population with poor diabetes control. Its selection is fair: every adult with diabetes seen at the two clinics is offered screening, not only those judged likely to be poor. Its risk-benefit balance is favorable because the screen is brief and each positive result leads to an offer of help. And respect for patients is built in through privacy, the right to decline, and follow-up that stops if the patient asks.

What this page is doingAn ethics framework is applied selectively and accurately, showing that the student understands which principles still govern QI.
6

Voluntary Participation and the Information Sheet

Because screening becomes part of routine care, the project will not collect signed consent, which the Hastings Center group judged unnecessary for minimal-risk improvement work integrated into usual care (Lynn et al., 2007). Patients will instead receive a one-page information sheet in English and Spanish, handed to them at check-in, that states:

The clinic is asking all patients with diabetes two questions about food, because food affects blood sugar. You can skip the questions, and skipping them will not change your care. If you tell us food has been hard to get, a community health worker can help you connect with the food bank today. Your answers go into your medical record like other health information and are protected the same way. A nursing student is studying how well this new process works, using information from records without your name.

Medical assistants will be trained to ask whether the patient is willing to answer before reading the questions, and to record a decline without comment.

What this page is doingThe information sheet is written at a plain-language level, states voluntariness and data use, and the training detail makes the right to decline real rather than nominal.
7

Risks and How They Are Minimized

The main risks are emotional and social rather than physical. Some patients may feel embarrassed or judged when asked about food. The questions will be asked privately in the exam room, not at the front desk, and in a neutral tone practiced during training. A second risk is disclosure: a record of food insecurity could be seen by people the patient did not intend. The screen result will be stored in the social history section with the same protections as other health information, and the food bank referral will share only the name, contact information, and household size the patient approves. A third risk is harm from screening without a response, which the project prevents by pairing every positive screen with an offer of same-day help. Patients who are undocumented or worried about public benefits will be told that the food bank does not ask about immigration status and that its help is not a public benefit, a message confirmed with the food bank before launch.

What this page is doingEach risk is named specifically with a matching safeguard, including a population-specific concern that patients themselves raised earlier in the proposal.
8

Data Management

The student will extract data monthly through a report built by the center's informatics analyst. The extract will contain a study number, clinic, visit date, screening result, referral and follow-up status, visit length, and most recent A1c, with no name, date of birth, address, or record number. The key linking study numbers to record numbers will remain with the analyst on the center's secure server and will not be shared with the student. The de-identified file will be stored on the university's encrypted storage, accessed only by the student and the faculty advisor, and destroyed three years after the project ends, following the university's retention policy. Results will be reported only in aggregate, and any cell with fewer than 10 patients will be suppressed to prevent identification in small subgroups.

What this page is doingData management names what is collected, who holds identifiers, where data are stored, who can access them, when they are destroyed and how small cells are handled, which is the detail reviewers request most often.
9

Site Approval and Conflicts of Interest

The submission includes the health center's letter of support signed by the medical director, confirming that the project aligns with the center's priorities and that the student may access data under the center's data use policy. The student is not employed by the health center and has no financial relationship with the food bank or any vendor. The site mentor is employed by the center, and her supervisory role in the clinic will be separated from the evaluation by having the student, not the mentor, extract and analyze data.

What this page is doingSite approval and conflicts of interest are addressed explicitly, including a potential role conflict and its management.
10

Reporting the Ethics Review

Whatever the board decides, the final project paper will state the determination, the date it was issued, and the protections used. The SQUIRE 2.0 reporting guidelines for improvement work ask authors to describe the ethical aspects of implementing and studying the intervention, including formal ethics review and any potential conflicts of interest (Ogrinc et al., 2016). Planning that description now keeps the ethical account consistent from submission to dissemination and signals to readers and journal editors that the question was taken seriously before any patient was asked about food.

What this page is doingLinking the review to the reporting standard the final paper will follow shows the student is planning the whole arc of the project.
11

Conclusion

This submission asks the board to determine that the food insecurity screening and referral project is quality improvement, based on its purpose, design, and risk, and describes protections the project will keep regardless: a plain-language information sheet with the right to decline, private screening, limited sharing, de-identified data with separated identifiers, suppression of small cells, and a guaranteed offer of help for every patient who screens positive.

What this page is doingThe conclusion restates the request and the protections in one place, which makes the reviewer's decision easy.
12

References

Emanuel, E. J., Wendler, D., & Grady, C. (2000). What makes clinical research ethical? JAMA, 283(20), 2701-2711. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.283.20.2701

Lynn, J., Baily, M. A., Bottrell, M., Jennings, B., Levine, R. J., Davidoff, F., Casarett, D., Corrigan, J., Fox, E., Wynia, M. K., Agich, G. J., O'Kane, M., Speroff, T., Schyve, P., Batalden, P., Tunis, S., Berlinger, N., Cronenwett, L., Fitzmaurice, J. M., ... James, B. (2007). The ethics of using quality improvement methods in health care. Annals of Internal Medicine, 146(9), 666-673. https://doi.org/10.7326/0003-4819-146-9-200705010-00155

Ogrinc, G., Davies, L., Goodman, D., Batalden, P., Davidoff, F., & Stevens, D. (2016). SQUIRE 2.0 (Standards for QUality Improvement Reporting Excellence): Revised publication guidelines from a detailed consensus process. BMJ Quality & Safety, 25(12), 986-992. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjqs-2015-004411

DNP880 Module 4 instructions, in plain terms

Module 4 in Aspen's DNP880 typically asks you to prepare documents for ethics review, including a quality improvement determination and the human subjects protections you will keep. Summarize the project in plain terms for reviewers. Argue whether it is improvement or research, using published criteria. Explain the protections you will keep either way. Describe how participation stays voluntary and what patients are told. Name risks and how each is minimized. Describe data management, from extraction to storage and destruction. Include site approval and any conflicts of interest. Explain how the determination will be reported. Keep the setting composite, and avoid arguing that improvement work needs no ethical attention, since reviewers read that as a warning sign.

How this DNP880 Module 4 example is built

The introduction states the request: a determination that the project is quality improvement. The summary section describes two questions at rooming, same-visit referral and a two-week follow-up call. The determination section applies the Hastings Center criteria on purpose, design and risk. The protections section lists conditions from Emanuel and colleagues that still apply, such as fair selection and favorable risk. The voluntary participation section explains why there is no signed consent and what the information sheet says. The risks section addresses embarrassment, privacy and the harm of screening without help. The data section lists the extract's fields with no names or dates of birth. Site approval, conflicts and reporting under SQUIRE 2.0 close the submission.

Reading the DNP880 Module 4 grading rubric

Ethics submissions in DNP880 are graded on a clear project summary, a reasoned determination, protections kept regardless of the decision, voluntariness, risk minimization, secure data handling and transparent reporting. This example earns credit by keeping protections even while arguing the project is not research, which reviewers value. The case for an improvement determination draws on the Hastings Center group led by Lynn, the protections on Emanuel, Wendler and Grady's seven conditions, and the reporting plan on SQUIRE 2.0. The data section, with listed fields and no identifiers, shows graders that privacy is designed in rather than promised.

DNP880 Module 4 help: mistakes that cost marks

Ethics papers often argue that a project is improvement and therefore needs nothing more. Keep protections anyway. Another frequent gap is a vague data plan; list the fields, storage and destruction date. Students also forget the harm of screening without a pathway to help. Name it and show the referral. Explain why signed consent is or is not needed with a source. Include site approval and conflicts. Write the summary for a reviewer outside nursing. Keep the setting composite. Avoid suggesting that publishing makes the project research, since intent at the start is what counts. Finally, state what you will do if the board decides the project needs full review, since a fallback plan keeps the timeline intact.

Write yours, or have the desk draft it

This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.

More DNP880 and DNP sample papers

DNP880 Module 4 questions, answered

What does DNP880 Module 4 usually ask for?

This part of the DNP project course typically asks for the documents your review board needs: a project summary, the case for a quality improvement or research determination, consent or information materials, risks and protections and a data management plan. Aspen does not publish module deliverables, so your classroom's instructions govern.

Does a DNP quality improvement project need IRB review?

Many QI projects are not human subjects research, but the student should not decide that alone. Submit the project for a formal determination by the university's review board, which decides the category.

Does publishing a QI project make it research?

Plans to publish do not by themselves make a project research, but institutions treat this differently, which is another reason to request a formal determination early.

Where can I find a free DNP880 Module 4 sample paper?

The complete DNP880 Module 4 paper is above, an ethics review submission asking the IRB to determine a food insecurity screening project is quality improvement.

Does a DNP880 quality improvement project still need protections?

Yes. The example keeps an information sheet, private questioning, a referral for every positive screen and a de-identified data extract, whatever the board decides.