HCA 125 Module 5 Capital Budgeting Analysis Example

Reviewed by Douglas Renshaw, MBA Aspen University Updated October 2026

This HCA 125 Module 5 sample paper asks whether Lakeview Regional Hospital, a composite not-for-profit, should spend $2.5 million on a second MRI scanner, judged by discounted cash flow, its rate of return and how fast it pays back. Aspen University's Health Care Administration program takes up capital budgeting in Module 5 of Healthcare Finance. The paper sets assumptions for a seven-year life, a $150,000 salvage value and 3,000 scans in year one, builds annual cash flows in a table and justifies an 8 percent cost of capital. Discounted at that rate, the scanner returns a net present value of about $1,105,700, an internal rate of return near 19.6 percent and payback in about 3.8 years. Sensitivity tests cut volume by 15 percent and price by 10 percent. Brealey, Myers and Allen and Reiter and Song frame the method, and Smith-Bindman adds imaging trends.

CourseHCA 125 Healthcare Finance
ModuleModule 5
Paper typeCapital budgeting analysis
LengthAbout 1,073 words, 6 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolAspen University
ProgramHealth Care Administration
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for HCA 125 Module 5

1

Is the Second MRI Worth $2.5 Million? Discounted Cash Flows, the Hurdle Rate and the Assumptions That Decide a Purchase

Student Name

Health Care Administration Program, Aspen University

HCA 125: Healthcare Finance

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this page is doingThe title poses the decision as a question with its price and names the methods, which tells the reader the paper will answer it with numbers. APA 7 student title page; the hospital and its figures are composite.
2

Is the Second MRI Worth $2.5 Million? Discounted Cash Flows, the Hurdle Rate and the Assumptions That Decide a Purchase

Buying major equipment commits an organization's money for years, so the decision should rest on the cash the equipment will produce over its life, valued in today's dollars. This paper evaluates whether Lakeview Regional Hospital, a composite not-for-profit hospital, should buy a second MRI scanner for its outpatient imaging center, where the existing scanner is booked three weeks out. It lays out the investment's cash flows, calculates net present value, internal rate of return, and payback, and tests how the answer changes when key assumptions move.

What this page is doingThe introduction states the decision, the reason it arises and the methods, keeping the analysis purpose-driven.
3

Why Discounted Cash Flow

A dollar received in year five is worth less than a dollar today, because today's dollar could be invested or used to pay down debt in the meantime. Net present value discounts each future cash flow at the organization's cost of capital and subtracts the initial investment; a positive value means the project earns more than the cost of the money it uses (Reiter & Song, 2021). The internal rate of return is the project's own yield, the rate that would make the discounted inflows exactly repay the investment, and payback is the number of years needed to recover the investment. Net present value is the primary decision rule because it measures value directly, while payback ignores cash flows after the payback point and ignores the time value of money (Brealey et al., 2020).

What this page is doingThe methods are defined with sources, and the paper explains why NPV is the primary rule and what payback misses.
4

Assumptions

The scanner and site preparation cost $2.5 million, paid now. The useful life is seven years, with a salvage value of $150,000. Volume starts at 3,000 scans in year one, about 10 a day over 300 operating days, based on the current waiting list and referral counts, and grows 2 percent a year. That growth rate is deliberately modest: in a study of seven U.S. health systems, annual growth in MRI use slowed to 1.3 percent among adults from 2007 to 2016 after rising more than 11 percent a year in the early 2000s (Smith-Bindman et al., 2019). Net revenue averages $420 per scan across the center's payer mix, and variable costs, including contrast, supplies, and billing, are $85 per scan. Fixed costs are $210,000 for two technologists including benefits, $60,000 for space and utilities, and a $140,000 service contract beginning in year two after the warranty ends. The hospital's cost of capital is 8 percent. As a not-for-profit hospital, Lakeview pays no income tax, so no tax effects are included.

What this page is doingEvery assumption is stated with its basis, and the growth rate is anchored in published utilization evidence reported accurately.
5

Cash Flows

Table 1 shows the annual cash flows.

YearScansNet revenueVariable costFixed costNet cash flow
0($2,500,000)
13,000$1,260,000$255,000$270,000$735,000
23,060$1,285,200$260,100$410,000$615,100
33,121$1,310,820$265,285$410,000$635,535
43,184$1,337,280$270,640$410,000$656,640
53,247$1,363,740$275,995$410,000$677,745
63,312$1,391,040$281,520$410,000$699,520
73,378$1,418,760$287,130$410,000$871,630 (includes $150,000 salvage)
What this page is doingThe cash flow table is laid out as a model would be, so each figure can be traced to the assumptions.
6

Choosing the Discount Rate

The 8 percent discount rate is the hospital's cost of capital, the blended return it must earn to satisfy the lenders who hold its bonds and to preserve the equity it has built from past surpluses. A not-for-profit hospital has no shareholders, but its equity still has a cost: money spent on a scanner cannot be used for another project or held as reserves. Using the cost of capital as the discount rate means that a positive net present value shows the project earns more than those alternatives. Because the rate itself is an estimate, the analysis also reports the result at 10 percent, a rate that would apply if the hospital's borrowing costs rose or if management judged outpatient imaging riskier than its average project.

What this page is doingExplaining where the discount rate comes from, and testing a higher one, addresses the assumption that most often goes unexamined in capital budgeting assignments.
7

Results

Discounted at 8 percent, the cash flows produce a net present value of about $1,105,700. The internal rate of return is about 19.6 percent, well above the 8 percent cost of capital, and payback occurs at about 3.8 years. At a 10 percent discount rate, the net present value is still about $865,500. On these assumptions the scanner is a sound investment. Depreciation does not appear in the cash flows because it is not a cash expense; the cost of the scanner is captured once, as the year-zero outflow.

What this page is doingResults are reported for the primary and an alternative discount rate, and the treatment of depreciation is explained, a common source of errors.
8

Sensitivity Analysis

The result depends on assumptions that could prove wrong, so each key assumption was varied. If volume starts 15 percent lower, at 2,550 scans, the net present value falls to about $277,300 and the internal rate of return to 11.1 percent. If net revenue per scan is 10 percent lower, at $378, perhaps because a large payer cuts imaging rates, the net present value falls to about $413,300. If both happen together, the project destroys value: net present value falls to about negative $311,300 and the internal rate of return to 4.4 percent. The break-even starting volume, holding other assumptions constant, is about 2,400 scans a year, or 8 a day. The scanner is a good investment unless volume and price fall together, and the hospital's current waiting list is the best evidence that volume will not.

What this page is doingSensitivity analysis tests each major assumption and their combination and finds the break-even volume, which turns the model into a risk judgment.
9

Factors the Numbers Do Not Capture

Some considerations fall outside the model. A three-week wait for MRI delays diagnosis and may send patients and referring physicians to competitors, so the second scanner may also protect volume in other services, such as orthopedic surgery, that depend on imaging. On the other side, a second scanner creates capacity that must be filled, and there is a risk of encouraging imaging that adds cost without benefit. The center should monitor the appropriateness of orders using national criteria, which protects both patients and the hospital's reputation with payers.

What this page is doingStrategic and ethical factors outside the model are weighed, including a risk that the investment could encourage low-value use.
10

Recommendation

Lakeview should buy the second MRI. The investment has a positive net present value of about $1.1 million at the hospital's cost of capital and remains positive under a 15 percent volume shortfall or a 10 percent price cut alone. Before committing, management should confirm the referral estimates behind the 3,000-scan starting volume and negotiate the service contract price, since those assumptions most affect the result. After purchase, volume should be tracked monthly against the model's 2,400-scan break-even.

What this page is doingThe recommendation follows from NPV and sensitivity, and names what to verify before and monitor after the purchase.
11

Conclusion

Discounted cash flow analysis shows that a second MRI at Lakeview would create value on reasonable assumptions, with a 19.6 percent internal rate of return and payback in under four years. The decision is robust to a single adverse change but not to a simultaneous drop in volume and price, which defines the risk management must watch.

What this page is doingThe conclusion restates the result and the specific risk that could overturn it.
12

References

Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

Reiter, K. L., & Song, P. H. (2021). Gapenski's healthcare finance: An introduction to accounting and financial management (7th ed.). Health Administration Press.

Smith-Bindman, R., Kwan, M. L., Marlow, E. C., Theis, M. K., Bolch, W., Cheng, S. Y., Bowles, E. J. A., Duncan, J. R., Greenlee, R. T., Kushi, L. H., Pole, J. D., Rahm, A. K., Stout, N. K., Weinmann, S., & Miglioretti, D. L. (2019). Trends in use of medical imaging in US health care systems and in Ontario, Canada, 2000-2016. JAMA, 322(9), 843-856. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2019.11456

Reading the HCA 125 Module 5 assignment instructions

Module 5 of Aspen's HCA 125 frequently asks for a capital budgeting analysis of an equipment purchase using NPV, IRR and payback. State every assumption with its source: cost, life, salvage, volume, revenue per unit, operating costs and taxes if any. Build annual cash flows in a table, excluding depreciation as a cash cost. Justify the discount rate. Calculate NPV, IRR and payback and explain what each shows. Test the key assumptions one at a time and together. Discuss factors the numbers miss. Make a recommendation with conditions. Keep the hospital composite, and explain why NPV is preferred over payback when the two point in different directions, since that is a common exam and assignment question.

How this HCA 125 Module 5 example is built

The introduction explains that equipment decisions commit money for years. The discounted cash flow section explains why a future dollar is worth less today. The assumptions section sets cost, life, salvage, volume from the waiting list and revenue and costs per scan. A table shows the annual cash flows. The discount rate section explains the hospital's 8 percent cost of capital and why a not-for-profit still has one. The results section reports NPV, IRR and payback and the effect of a 10 percent rate. The sensitivity section shows NPV falling to about $277,300 with lower volume and turning negative if volume and price both fall. The factors section covers wait times, referrals and protecting surgical volume, and the recommendation supports buying with conditions.

Reading the HCA 125 Module 5 grading rubric

An HCA 125 equipment analysis is marked on stated assumptions, clean cash flows, a defended rate, correct results, tested sensitivities and a clear call. The scanner still pays off if volume or price slips alone, but not if both do, and saying so openly earns marks. Discounting follows standard corporate finance, its hospital application follows the Gapenski text and rising imaging use, documented by Smith-Bindman, supports the volume forecast. Explaining why a not-for-profit has a cost of capital shows a concept many students miss. The section on factors outside the model keeps the recommendation grounded in operations.

HCA 125 Module 5 help from the desk

Capital papers often include depreciation as a cash outflow. Leave it out, except for tax effects. A rate pulled from nowhere is another weak spot, so show how the hospital's 8 percent is built. Students also rely on payback alone. Lead with NPV. Test assumptions one at a time and in combination. State volume sources. Include salvage value. Discuss factors the model misses, such as wait times and referral loyalty. Keep the hospital composite and the scanner's figures the same in every table. Show the cash flow table. Finally, set conditions in the recommendation, such as confirming referral commitments before signing, since a positive NPV built on optimistic volume can turn negative within the first year.

Write yours, or have the desk draft it

This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.

More HCA 125 and Health Care Administration sample papers

HCA 125 Module 5 questions, answered

What does HCA 125 Module 5 usually ask for?

Work in this part of HCA 125 often asks for a capital budgeting or time value of money analysis, such as whether to buy a piece of equipment, using NPV, IRR and payback. Aspen does not publish module deliverables, so your classroom's instructions govern.

Why is NPV preferred over payback?

NPV accounts for the time value of money and all cash flows over the asset's life, while payback ignores cash flows after the investment is recovered and does not discount future dollars.

Should depreciation be included in capital budgeting cash flows?

Not as a cash outflow, since the purchase price is already counted at year zero. For taxable organizations, depreciation matters only through the tax savings it creates.

Where can I find a free HCA 125 Module 5 sample paper?

The complete HCA 125 Module 5 paper is above, evaluating a $2.5 million second MRI with NPV, IRR, payback and sensitivity analysis.

When does the second MRI stop paying off in HCA 125 Module 5?

It stays positive if volume falls 15 percent or price falls 10 percent on its own, but not if both slip at once, so the advice to buy is conditional.