| Course | HCA 320 Healthcare Policy and Economics |
|---|---|
| Module | Module 3 |
| Paper type | Policy process paper |
| Length | About 1,106 words, 7 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Aspen University |
| Program | Health Care Administration |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 320 Module 3
From Headlines to Law to Court: How the No Surprises Act Was Made and Remade
Student Name
Health Care Administration Program, Aspen University
HCA 320: Healthcare Policy and Economics
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
From Headlines to Law to Court: How the No Surprises Act Was Made and Remade
Health policy is not made once; it is proposed, bargained over, enacted, written into regulations, challenged, and revised. The federal law that ended most surprise medical bills shows each of those stages within a few years. This paper describes the problem the law addressed, uses Kingdon's multiple streams framework to explain why it passed when it did, identifies the stakeholders who shaped its design, and follows its implementation through rulemaking and litigation, drawing lessons for healthcare professionals who want to influence policy.
The Problem
A surprise bill arises when a patient receives care from a clinician or facility outside their insurance network without choosing to, most often in an emergency or when an out-of-network anesthesiologist, radiologist, or pathologist works at an in-network hospital. The patient may then be billed for the difference between the clinician's charge and what the insurer pays. The problem grew. Analyzing claims from a large commercial insurer, Sun et al. (2019) found that the share of emergency visits with an out-of-network bill rose from 32.3 percent in 2010 to 42.8 percent in 2016, and the share of inpatient admissions with such a bill rose from 26.3 to 42.0 percent. Cooper et al. (2020) found that at in-network hospitals, 11.8 percent of anesthesiology care and 12.3 percent of care involving a pathologist were billed out of network, and argued that the ability to bill out of network let these specialists negotiate higher in-network rates as well.
Why It Passed When It Did: Kingdon's Three Streams
Kingdon (2011) argued that policy change happens when three largely independent streams come together. The problem stream is the recognition of a condition as a problem requiring action. The policy stream is the set of proposed solutions developed by specialists. The political stream includes public mood, elections, and the balance of interests. When the three meet, a window opens, and policy entrepreneurs can push a proposal through.
Each stream was in place by 2019 and 2020. In the problem stream, studies like those above, along with widely reported patient stories of bills for thousands of dollars after emergencies, made surprise billing a visible problem. In the policy stream, many states had already passed their own protections, which gave federal legislators tested models, but state laws could not reach self-funded employer plans governed by federal law, which left many patients unprotected and created a clear federal role. In the political stream, the issue was unusual in drawing concern from both parties, since protecting patients from unexpected bills was popular across the political spectrum. The window opened at the end of 2020, when the protections were included in the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021, a large spending bill that had to pass. Bipartisan appeal got the idea onto the agenda; a must-pass bill got it into law.
Stakeholders and the Fight Over Design
Agreement on protecting patients did not mean agreement on who would pay. The central design question was how to set payment for out-of-network care once patients were held harmless. Insurers and many employers favored a benchmark, paying out-of-network clinicians based on typical in-network rates, which would limit their costs. Physician groups, hospitals, and physician staffing companies opposed a benchmark and favored independent arbitration, which they expected to produce higher payments. The final law adopted arbitration, called independent dispute resolution, in which an arbiter chooses between the insurer's and the provider's offers, while directing the arbiter to consider the qualifying payment amount, generally the insurer's median in-network rate, along with other factors. The compromise reflected the political strength of both sides.
What the Law Does
The No Surprises Act took effect on January 1, 2022. It protects patients from surprise bills for emergency services, for nonemergency services from out-of-network clinicians at in-network facilities in most circumstances, and for air ambulance services. Patients pay only their in-network cost sharing, and payment disputes are settled between providers and insurers. Uninsured and self-pay patients have a right to a good faith estimate of expected charges (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services [CMS], 2025). Ground ambulance services were not covered by the main protections, one of the law's notable gaps.
Implementation and Change After Enactment
Enactment was not the end of policymaking. Three federal departments had to write regulations explaining how the arbitration process would work. Provider groups challenged those rules in federal court, arguing that they told arbiters to give too much weight to the qualifying payment amount, and federal courts in Texas set aside parts of the rules. The departments revised them. The dispute over how much weight the benchmark should carry, which Congress had resolved by compromise, returned through rulemaking and litigation. The episode illustrates a general point: stakeholders who lose in the legislature often continue the contest in regulation and the courts.
Advocacy for the Patients the Law Missed
The law's gaps show where advocacy can still matter. Ground ambulance bills were left out of the main protections, although patients rarely choose which ambulance comes for them, and Congress directed an advisory committee to study the issue instead. Patients in that situation have the same lack of choice that justified the law in the first place. A healthcare administrator or professional association that documents local ground ambulance billing, collects patient cases, and brings them to state legislators or members of Congress would be following the same path that produced the original law: evidence in the problem stream, a model solution in the policy stream, and a push when the political stream allows.
Lessons for Healthcare Professionals
Three lessons follow for professionals who want to influence policy. First, evidence moves problems onto the agenda: the studies documenting out-of-network billing gave legislators numbers to cite. Second, the details are where interests are decided, so engaging during drafting and rulemaking, through comment letters and professional associations, can matter as much as supporting a bill's passage. Third, patient stories carry weight, and clinicians and administrators who see the effects of policy directly can provide them. Administrators also have an operational role: hospitals must now give notices and good faith estimates and ensure their contracted physicians comply, so policy knowledge is part of the job.
Conclusion
The No Surprises Act moved from a documented problem to federal law when Kingdon's three streams converged: rising out-of-network billing, tested state models with a clear federal gap, and bipartisan politics, carried by a must-pass bill. Its design reflected a compromise among insurers, employers, and providers, and that compromise was reopened in rulemaking and court. Policy is developed and changed continuously, and those who understand the process can take part at every stage.
References
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2025). No surprises: Understand your rights against surprise medical bills. https://www.cms.gov/nosurprises
Cooper, Z., Nguyen, H., Shekita, N., & Scott Morton, F. (2020). Out-of-network billing and negotiated payments for hospital-based physicians. Health Affairs, 39(1), 24-32. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2019.00507
Kingdon, J. W. (2011). Agendas, alternatives, and public policies (Updated 2nd ed.). Longman.
Sun, E. C., Mello, M. M., Moshfegh, J., & Baker, L. C. (2019). Assessment of out-of-network billing for privately insured patients receiving care in in-network hospitals. JAMA Internal Medicine, 179(11), 1543-1550. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2019.3451
HCA 320 Module 3 instructions, in plain terms
Aspen's HCA 320 Module 3 frequently asks you to describe how a specific health policy was developed and changed. Choose a policy with a clear history. Define the problem with evidence. Use a recognized policy process framework to explain why it moved when it did. Identify stakeholders and the design choices they fought over. Summarize what the policy does accurately. Follow implementation, including regulations and legal challenges. Name gaps the policy left and who is still exposed to unexpected bills. Draw lessons for health care professionals who want to influence policy. Use primary sources such as agency guidance, and keep dates precise, since the sequence of events is part of what the assignment assesses.
How this HCA 320 Module 3 example is built
The introduction says policy is proposed, bargained, enacted, written into rules, challenged and revised. The problem section explains how surprise bills arise and reports research on how often they occur. The Kingdon section shows the problem, policy and politics streams converging, with a must-pass spending bill as the vehicle. The stakeholder section explains why insurers and employers favored a benchmark and providers favored arbitration. The law section explains who is now shielded, from emergency patients to people treated by outside anesthesiologists at network hospitals and air ambulance riders. The implementation section follows three departments' rules, court challenges and revised rules. The advocacy section names ground ambulance bills and other gaps. Three lessons for professionals and a conclusion follow.
HCA 320 Module 3 rubric: what earns full marks
Policy process papers in HCA 320 are graded on an accurate problem statement, correct use of a process framework, attention to stakeholders and design, an accurate summary of the policy and recognition that implementation continues to shape it. This example earns credit by following the law past enactment into regulations and courts, which many papers omit. Kingdon's 2011 updated edition of Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies supplies the framework. Sun and colleagues' 2019 study in JAMA Internal Medicine and Cooper and colleagues' 2020 Health Affairs study document the problem, and the 2025 CMS consumer guidance summarizes the law's protections. Naming gaps such as ground ambulances shows where advocacy remains possible, which connects the paper to professional action.
HCA 320 Module 3 help: mistakes that cost marks
Process papers often stop at the bill's signing. Follow implementation. Another common gap is naming Kingdon's streams without applying them; show each one with evidence. Students also describe the law vaguely. List its protections precisely. Explain the stakeholder fight over payment design. Cite primary sources such as the law, agency rules and court decisions. Keep dates accurate. Name gaps the policy left. Avoid taking sides in the payment dispute without evidence. Finally, end with one action a health care manager could take, such as checking that the organization's good faith estimates for uninsured patients meet the rule, since policy lessons are strongest when they reach the workplace.
Write yours, or have the desk draft it
This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.
More HCA 320 and Health Care Administration sample papers
- HCA 320 Module 1: Health Care Market Economics
- HCA 320 Module 2: Reimbursement Models Discussion
- HCA 320 Module 4: Medicaid Coverage Gap Analysis
- HCA 320 Module 5: Policy Advocacy Brief
- HCA 320 Module 6: Drug Price Policy Discussion
- HCA 320 Module 7: Competitive Analysis and SWOT
- HCA 320 Module 8: Executive Brief and Proposal
- HCA 110 Module 4: Completing a Clean Claim
- HCA 130 Module 3: Plain Language for Patients
- HCA 125 Module 1: Healthcare Financial Structure
- HCA 205 Module 8: A High Blood Pressure Prevention Handout
HCA 320 Module 3 questions, answered
What does HCA 320 Module 3 usually ask for?
Work in this part of HCA 320 often asks how a health policy is developed, enacted and changed, and how stakeholders influence it. Aspen does not publish module deliverables, so your classroom's instructions govern.
What is Kingdon's multiple streams framework?
A model in which policy change occurs when three streams, problems, policy proposals and politics, converge and open a window that policy entrepreneurs can use to move a proposal into law.
Where can I find a free HCA 320 Module 3 sample paper?
The complete HCA 320 Module 3 paper is above, following the No Surprises Act from the problem through Kingdon's streams, enactment, regulations and court challenges.
How does Kingdon's framework explain the No Surprises Act in HCA 320 Module 3?
Research made surprise billing a recognized problem, state laws offered tested solutions and bipartisan politics aligned, so a must-pass spending bill carried the law in December 2020.
What does the No Surprises Act protect patients from in HCA 320 Module 3?
Bills above in-network cost sharing for emergency care, for most planned care by outside clinicians at network hospitals and for air ambulance rides; uninsured patients also get a good faith estimate.