| Course | N520 Legal and Ethical Issues in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Module | Module 2 |
| Paper type | Case response paper |
| Length | About 1,063 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Aspen University |
| Program | MSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for N520 Module 2
Duty, Breach, Causation, Harm: Analyzing Nursing Negligence, Defenses, and Documentation in a Composite Hospital Fall
Student Name
Master of Science in Nursing Program, Aspen University
N520: Legal and Ethical Issues in Health Care
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Duty, Breach, Causation, Harm: Analyzing Nursing Negligence, Defenses, and Documentation in a Composite Hospital Fall
This paper answers the Module 2 prompts using a composite case. Mrs. P., 78, was admitted to a medical unit at 10 p.m. with pneumonia and new confusion. The admitting nurse completed a brief assessment but did not record a fall risk score or order a bed alarm. At 1 a.m., a physician resident ordered a sedating medication for agitation by telephone. The nurse gave it but did not reassess Mrs. P. for three hours because two other patients deteriorated and the unit was short one nurse. At 4 a.m., Mrs. P. was found on the floor with a hip fracture, which required surgery. She later sued the nurse, the resident, and the hospital.
Evidence That Establishes a Negligent Act
Negligence requires the plaintiff to prove four elements: a duty owed, a breach of the standard of care, causation, and harm (Guido, 2020). Duty arises from the nurse-patient relationship; once the nurse accepted Mrs. P.'s assignment, the duty was established (Brous, 2019a). Breach is measured against what a reasonably prudent nurse would do in similar circumstances, and the plaintiff typically shows it with an expert witness, the hospital's own policies, and published professional standards (Brous, 2019b). Here, evidence of breach would include the missing fall risk assessment, the absence of a bed alarm for a confused older patient, and the three-hour gap in reassessment after a sedative.
Causation asks whether the injury probably would not have happened without the breach, judged on the civil standard of a preponderance of the evidence (Brous, 2019c). The defense might argue that Mrs. P. could have fallen even with an alarm, but an expert could testify that timely reassessment and fall precautions would likely have prevented an unsupervised attempt to get up. Harm is clear: a hip fracture requiring surgery, with pain, disability, and costs (Brous, 2020). Each element must be proven separately; a documentation gap alone proves breach only if it reflects care that was not given.
Defenses Available to the Nurse
The nurse's defenses include challenging causation, as above; arguing that the standard of care was met given the circumstances, including the unit's emergencies and short staffing; and asserting comparative negligence if Mrs. P. had been instructed to call for help and understood the instruction, which is unlikely given her confusion (Guido, 2020). Short staffing is not a complete defense, since the nurse remained responsible for prioritizing and seeking help, but it can shift some responsibility to the hospital. A procedural defense, the statute of limitations, is discussed below.
How Statutes of Limitations Protect Nurse-Defendants
A statute of limitations sets the time within which a lawsuit must be filed, commonly two to three years for professional negligence, depending on the state (Guido, 2020). The period usually begins when the injury occurs or, under the discovery rule, when the patient knew or reasonably should have known of it. For minors, the period is often extended until they reach majority. These statutes protect defendants from claims brought after evidence and memories have faded. In Mrs. P.'s case, the injury was known immediately, so the period began on the day of the fall.
Preventing Quasi-Intentional Torts
Quasi-intentional torts involve harm to a person's reputation, privacy, or dignity rather than physical injury. They include defamation, which is a false statement that harms reputation (slander when spoken, libel when written), and invasion of privacy or breach of confidentiality (Guido, 2020). After Mrs. P.'s fall, a nurse who wrote in the chart that the night nurse "was lazy and ignored her patient" or who discussed the fall with visitors in the hallway would risk exactly such a claim. Nurses prevent these torts by documenting facts rather than opinions, discussing patients only with those who need to know, never posting about patients on social media, and reporting concerns about colleagues through proper channels rather than in the medical record.
Why Admission Documentation Matters
The admission assessment establishes the patient's baseline and identifies risks that shape the plan of care. A documented fall risk score for Mrs. P. would have triggered precautions under most hospital policies and would have shown that the nurse recognized the risk. Its absence suggests the risk was not assessed. In litigation, the record is often the most important evidence, and juries tend to believe that care not documented was not performed (Brous, 2019b). Complete, timely admission documentation protects the patient by guiding care and protects the nurse by showing that the standard was met.
Determining Liability Among Several Defendants
Liability can be shared. The nurse is personally liable for her own negligence. The hospital is vicariously liable for its employees' negligence under the doctrine of respondeat superior, and it may also be directly liable under corporate negligence for inadequate staffing and for failing to ensure that fall-prevention policies were followed (Guido, 2020). The resident may be liable if ordering a sedative without assessing a confused older patient fell below the physician standard of care. In many states, a jury apportions fault among defendants by percentage; depending on state law, defendants may be jointly and severally liable, so that the plaintiff can collect the full judgment from any one of them. In practice, the hospital, with its insurance and direct role in staffing, would likely bear the largest share.
Lessons for Nurse Leaders
For a graduate-prepared nurse in a leadership role, the case points to systems as much as to individuals. A unit that is routinely short one nurse on nights, with no process for redistributing assignments when two patients deteriorate at once, creates conditions in which reassessments are missed. Leaders can reduce that risk by building fall risk scoring into the admission workflow so it cannot be skipped, requiring reassessment within a set time after sedating medications, escalating staffing shortfalls through a documented chain of command, and reviewing falls as system events rather than only as individual failures. These measures protect patients first, and they also strengthen the hospital's defense against a corporate negligence claim.
Conclusion
Mrs. P.'s case shows how negligence is built from four elements, how defenses and statutes of limitations limit liability, how quasi-intentional torts can follow careless words, and how responsibility is shared among nurse, physician, and hospital. The most practical lesson is that careful assessment and documentation at admission, and timely reassessment afterward, protect both patients and nurses.
References
Brous, E. (2019a). The elements of a nursing malpractice case, part 1: Duty. American Journal of Nursing, 119(7), 64-67. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.NAJ.0000569476.17357.f5
Brous, E. (2019b). The elements of a nursing malpractice case, part 2: Breach. American Journal of Nursing, 119(9), 42-46. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.NAJ.0000580256.10914.2e
Brous, E. (2019c). The elements of a nursing malpractice case, part 3A: Causation. American Journal of Nursing, 119(11), 54-59. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.NAJ.0000605380.52689.af
Brous, E. (2020). The elements of a nursing malpractice case, part 4: Harm. American Journal of Nursing, 120(3), 61-64. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.NAJ.0000656360.21284.50
Guido, G. W. (2020). Legal and ethical issues in nursing (7th ed.). Pearson.
What the N520 Module 2 instructions ask for
Aspen's N520 Module 2 commonly asks for a Word document answering the textbook's end-of-chapter negligence cases: the evidence for a negligent act, defenses, statutes of limitations, quasi-intentional torts, documentation and liability among defendants. Your classroom lists the cases and questions. Answer each question with a heading. Name the elements of negligence and match evidence to each. Explain defenses honestly, including their limits. Explain filing deadlines in general terms, noting that states differ. Define quasi-intentional torts with examples and prevention. Explain why admission records matter in litigation. Show how liability can be shared among nurses, physicians and the hospital. Use the textbook and peer-reviewed legal nursing sources.
How this N520 Module 2 example is built
The introduction states that the paper answers the prompts through a composite fall. The evidence section explains each element a plaintiff must prove and what would prove it: the duty arising from assignment, a breach shown by the fall risk policy and records, causation and the injury itself. The defenses section covers disputing causation, arguing that the standard of care was met during emergencies and short staffing, and comparative negligence if the patient got up against instructions. A section explains how statutes of limitations bar late claims. The torts section covers defamation, invasion of privacy and how to prevent them. The documentation section explains why the admission fall risk assessment shapes the case. A liability section and lessons for leaders on staffing and systems close it.
Where the marks sit in the N520 Module 2 rubric
Marks in this paper follow complete answers to each case question with accurate legal concepts. The evidence section maps proof to each element rather than listing the elements alone, which is what the prompt asks. Defenses are explained with their limits. The statute of limitations answer is accurate in general and notes state variation. Quasi-intentional torts are defined and paired with prevention. Brous's 2019 AJN articles on duty, breach and causation, labeled 2019a to 2019c, and the Guido textbook supply the law, all listed in APA 7. The leadership section moves from individual fault to system design, which suits a graduate course. Each answer sits under its own heading, so each reply lines up with its numbered question.
Common N520 Module 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
The most common error is listing the four elements without showing what evidence would prove each in the case. Another is presenting defenses as excuses; explain the legal reasoning. Students also give a single statute of limitations number for all states. Say it varies and give a typical range. Quasi-intentional torts are often confused with intentional ones; define the difference. Documentation answers should explain how records are used as evidence. Shared liability should name the legal theories, such as an employer's responsibility for staff. Cite Guido and at least one legal nursing article. Use a composite case and avoid naming real lawsuits unless you cite them properly.
Write yours, or have the desk draft it
This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.
More N520 and MSN sample papers
- N520 Module 1: Ethical Issues Case Responses
- N520 Module 3: Liability Insurance Case Responses
- N520 Module 4: Standards and Delegation Case Responses
- N520 Module 5: Informed Consent Case Responses
- N520 Module 6: Patient Safety and Scope Cases
- N520 Module 7: Legal and Ethical Capstone
- N520 Module 8: Privacy and Social Media Cases
- N511 Module 1: Shadow Health Reflection
- N684 Module 6: Medication Management at Home
- N564 Module 8: Compassion Fatigue and Self-Care
- N538 Module 1: Informatics Language
N520 Module 2 questions, answered
What does N520 Module 2 usually ask for?
A Word document answering the textbook's end-of-chapter negligence cases: what evidence establishes a negligent act, available defenses, statutes of limitations, preventing quasi-intentional torts, the importance of admission documentation and how liability is determined among defendants.
What are the four elements of nursing negligence?
Duty, breach of the standard of care, causation and harm. The plaintiff must prove each one, usually with expert testimony for breach and causation.
What is a quasi-intentional tort?
A tort that harms reputation, privacy or dignity rather than the body, such as defamation (slander or libel) and invasion of privacy or breach of confidentiality. Documenting facts rather than opinions and discussing patients only with those who need to know prevents them.
Where can I find a free N520 Module 2 sample paper?
The complete N520 Module 2 paper is above, analyzing a composite hospital fall for negligence evidence, defenses, documentation and shared liability.
What evidence proves nursing negligence in the N520 Module 2 case?
Evidence of the nurse's assignment establishes duty, policy and records show breach, expert testimony links the breach to the injury, and medical records document the harm.