| Course | N522 Modern Organizations and Health Care |
|---|---|
| Module | Module 2 |
| Paper type | Organizational structure analysis |
| Length | About 1,054 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Aspen University |
| Program | MSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for N522 Module 2
Two Bosses and No Answer: Analyzing a Matrix Reporting Structure for Nurses in a 12-Clinic Primary Care Network
Student Name
Master of Science in Nursing Program, Aspen University
N522: Modern Organizations and Health Care
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Two Bosses and No Answer: Analyzing a Matrix Reporting Structure for Nurses in a 12-Clinic Primary Care Network
Organizational structure determines who decides, who is accountable, and how information moves. In health care, structure shapes whether a nurse with a question gets an answer in five minutes or five days. This paper analyzes the reporting structure for registered nurses in a composite primary care network, uses Mintzberg's configurations and research on matrix management to diagnose its problems, and proposes a redesign.
The Network and Its Structure
Valley Community Health is a composite network of 12 primary care clinics with 64 registered nurses, 90 medical assistants, and 70 physicians and advanced practice providers. Four years ago, to standardize nursing practice across sites, the network created a central Director of Clinical Nursing. Clinic RNs now report to two people: their clinic's practice manager, usually a nonclinical administrator who controls schedules, time off, and daily assignments, and the director, who sets clinical protocols, competencies, and performance standards. It is a classic matrix: a functional nursing line crossing a geographic clinic line.
The results are mixed. Clinical protocols are more consistent than before, and nurses value having a clinical leader. But nurses report conflicting instructions, such as a practice manager asking an RN to cover the front desk while the director expects the nurse to complete care management calls. Annual evaluations are written by practice managers who cannot judge clinical performance. Turnover among clinic RNs reached 22 percent last year, and exit interviews frequently mention "not knowing who my boss is."
Diagnosis Using Mintzberg's Configurations
Mintzberg (1979) described organizations by the part that dominates them and the way they coordinate work. Primary care clinics resemble a professional bureaucracy, in which highly trained professionals coordinate through standardized skills learned in their training rather than through direct supervision. In such organizations, professionals expect autonomy over clinical work and resist control by administrators who lack their expertise.
The practice manager line applies direct supervision, the coordination mechanism of a simple structure or machine bureaucracy, to professionals whose work is coordinated by standardized skills. When a nonclinical manager reassigns an RN from care management to reception, the manager treats nursing time as a generic resource, while the nurse and the director see it as professional work with clinical consequences. The conflict is not about personalities; it is built into a structure that asks two coordination mechanisms to govern the same hour of a nurse's day.
What Research on Matrix Structures Suggests
Matrix structures were widely adopted by hospitals in the 1970s and 1980s, and many were later abandoned. In a study of U.S. hospitals, Burns and Wholey (1993) found that adoption was influenced by organizational characteristics, such as size and the diversity of services, and by imitation of other hospitals in the same networks, and that abandonment was also shaped by what peer organizations did rather than only by whether the matrix worked internally. The finding suggests that matrix structures are often chosen because they are fashionable rather than because they fit the work.
Matrix structures can succeed when the two lines have clearly divided authority and a shared process for resolving conflicts. They fail when both lines claim the same decisions. At Valley, both managers claim control over how RN time is used, and there is no mechanism for resolving the conflict other than the nurse's own judgment, which leaves the nurse exposed to criticism from whichever boss is disappointed.
An older distinction helps explain why. Burns and Stalker (1961) contrasted mechanistic structures, with clear hierarchies and fixed roles suited to stable conditions, and organic structures, with fluid roles and lateral communication suited to changing conditions. Primary care has become more organic in its demands, with nurses managing chronic disease, coordinating transitions, and responding to walk-in needs, yet the practice manager line still treats the clinic as a mechanistic unit with fixed posts to fill. A structure built for a stable front office sits uneasily on professional work that changes by the hour.
The Costs of the Current Design
The structure has measurable costs. Replacing an RN in primary care costs a substantial share of annual salary once recruitment, orientation, and lost productivity are counted, so a 22 percent turnover rate among 64 nurses means about 14 departures a year and a large recurring expense. Care management calls that are postponed when nurses are pulled to the front desk translate into missed follow-up for patients with diabetes and heart failure, the patients whose avoidable emergency visits the network is trying to reduce. And evaluations by nonclinical managers deprive nurses of meaningful feedback on the work they were hired to do.
A Redesigned Structure
The proposal keeps the benefits of the matrix while dividing authority clearly. Clinical nursing work, including protocols, competencies, care management priorities, and clinical performance evaluation, would belong to the nursing line, with a new role of regional nurse manager overseeing four clinics each and reporting to the director. Operational matters, including clinic hours, space, and nonclinical staffing, would remain with practice managers. RN schedules would be set jointly, with a written rule that RNs are not reassigned to nonclinical duties except in declared emergencies.
A monthly clinic operations meeting including the practice manager and the regional nurse manager would resolve conflicts before they reach the nurse. Success would be measured by RN turnover, completion rates for care management calls, and nurse survey responses about role clarity, reviewed at six and twelve months.
Implementation would begin with the clinics where turnover has been highest, so the network can test the new division of authority before extending it to all 12 sites. Practice managers would need reassurance that they are not losing influence, since they remain accountable for clinic operations and patient access, and a short written charter signed by both lines would make the division of decisions visible to staff.
Conclusion
Valley's matrix brought clinical consistency but placed nurses between two coordination systems that claim the same decisions. Mintzberg's configurations explain why professionals resist direct supervision by nonclinical managers, and research on matrix management suggests that such structures fail when authority is not clearly divided. A redesign that assigns clinical decisions to a nursing line, operational decisions to clinic managers, and conflicts to a joint forum should reduce turnover and protect the care management work that patients depend on.
References
Burns, L. R., & Wholey, D. R. (1993). Adoption and abandonment of matrix management programs: Effects of organizational characteristics and interorganizational networks. Academy of Management Journal, 36(1), 106-138. https://doi.org/10.5465/256514
Burns, T., & Stalker, G. M. (1961). The management of innovation. Tavistock.
Mintzberg, H. (1979). The structuring of organizations: A synthesis of the research. Prentice-Hall.
N522 Module 2 instructions, in plain terms
Aspen's N522 Module 2 typically covers organizational structure and design and its assignment usually has you study one organization's structure, then suggest changes. Describe the structure precisely: who reports to whom and who decides what. Diagnose it with a recognized framework. Use research on similar structures. Show the costs of the current design with evidence or measures. Propose a redesign that keeps what works and fixes what does not. Explain how the change would roll out and the measure that would show it worked. A simple organizational chart, described in words or included as a figure, helps a reader follow the reporting lines you are analyzing.
Inside the N522 Module 2 example
The introduction states that structure determines who decides and how information moves. The network section describes Valley's 12 clinics, staff numbers and dual reporting lines, with mixed results. The diagnosis applies Mintzberg's configurations and coordination mechanisms, showing practice managers supervising professionals whose work is coordinated by training and standards. The research section explains why many hospitals adopted and then abandoned matrix management, and when matrix designs succeed: divided authority and a shared way to resolve conflict. Burns and Stalker's distinction adds a reason. The costs section lists turnover, delays and conflicting instructions. The redesign gives clinical practice decisions to the nurse line and operations to the practice line, adds a monthly meeting and starts in the clinics with the highest turnover.
Where the marks sit in the N522 Module 2 rubric
Structure papers in this course are judged on precise description, a framework-based diagnosis, use of research, measured costs and a workable redesign. The diagnosis is the strongest part because it explains why the conflict happens, not only that it happens. Research on matrix management gives the proposal an evidence base. Costs are concrete. The redesign divides authority explicitly and includes a conflict process. Burns and Stalker's 1961 book, Burns and Wholey's 1993 study and Mintzberg's 1979 book are cited in APA 7. The phased rollout shows practical planning, and the conclusion states what the matrix gained and what it cost. Because the redesign assigns each disputed decision to one line, a grader can see exactly how it ends the two-boss problem.
Common N522 Module 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Weak structure papers describe an organizational chart and stop. Diagnose why the structure causes problems. Another gap is proposing a new chart without saying who decides what, which is the heart of structure. Students also cite general management books without research on health care organizations. Use at least one study. Costs should be measurable, such as turnover or delays. Avoid naming real managers or clinics. Keep the redesign realistic; flattening everything rarely works in health care. Plan for implementation, including where to start. Finally, connect your diagnosis to the redesign so each change fixes a named problem. Include the reporting lines as a simple figure or a short list if your instructor permits it.
Write yours, or have the desk draft it
This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.
More N522 and MSN sample papers
- N522 Module 1: Organizational Theory
- N522 Module 3: Organizational Culture Assessment
- N522 Module 4: Organizational Analysis Paper
- N522 Module 5: Team Conflict and Communication
- N522 Module 6: Planned Change
- N522 Module 7: Staffing Decision
- N522 Module 8: Organizational Analysis and Change
- N508 Module 8: Theory, Research, and Practice
- N518 Module 8: Comprehensive Assessment Reflection
- N684 Module 8: Home Health and Community Paramedicine
- N680 Module 6: Public Health Policy Analysis
N522 Module 2 questions, answered
What does N522 Module 2 usually ask for?
The module typically covers organizational structure and design, often asking you to analyze how reporting lines and design choices shape work in an organization you know. Aspen does not publish module deliverables, so your classroom's instructions govern.
What is a professional bureaucracy?
Mintzberg's term for an organization, such as a hospital or clinic, in which highly trained professionals coordinate through standardized skills from their training rather than through direct supervision, and expect autonomy over their clinical work.
Why do matrix structures cause conflict?
Staff report to two managers. When both claim the same decisions and there is no mechanism to resolve disagreements, the employee is caught between conflicting instructions. Clear division of authority and a joint forum reduce the problem.
Where can I find a free N522 Module 2 sample paper?
The complete N522 Module 2 paper is above, diagnosing a two-boss matrix structure in a 12-clinic primary care network and proposing a redesign.
Which structure does the N522 Module 2 network use?
Twelve clinics with dual reporting lines, read through Mintzberg's configurations: practice managers supervise professionals whose work is really coordinated by training and standards.