| Course | N564 Advanced Forensic Nursing |
|---|---|
| Module | Module 6 |
| Paper type | Policy analysis paper |
| Length | About 1,089 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Aspen University |
| Program | MSN |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for N564 Module 6
Protection or Harm? Mandatory Reporting of Adult Intimate Partner Violence and the Forensic Nurse's Advocacy
Student Name
Master of Science in Nursing Program, Aspen University
N564: Advanced Forensic Nursing
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Protection or Harm? Mandatory Reporting of Adult Intimate Partner Violence and the Forensic Nurse's Advocacy
A composite 31-year-old woman comes to an emergency department in a state that requires clinicians to report injuries from assaultive conduct to police. She has a fractured finger and tells the triage nurse that her husband twisted it. When the nurse explains that the hospital must notify law enforcement, she stops talking, asks for a splint and leaves before the physician sees her. She does not return for follow-up care.
Most states require health professionals to report suspected abuse of children, and many require reports of abuse of vulnerable or older adults. A smaller number go further, requiring clinicians to report injuries to competent adults resulting from intimate partner violence or other assault, regardless of the patient's wishes. This paper examines the purpose of such laws, the evidence on survivors' views and on the laws' effects, the ethical conflict they create for nurses, and a policy alternative that forensic nurses can advocate for.
The Purpose of the Laws
Mandatory reporting laws for adult intimate partner violence rest on reasonable goals: to hold abusers accountable, to relieve victims of the burden and danger of reporting themselves, to create a record that may support later prosecution, and to signal that partner violence is a crime rather than a private matter. California's law, for example, requires health practitioners who treat a patient for an injury they know or suspect was caused by assaultive or abusive conduct to report it to law enforcement. Supporters argue that without such laws, many assaults would never reach the justice system.
What Survivors Think
Survivors are divided. In a survey of 1,218 women in 12 emergency departments in California and Pennsylvania, Rodríguez et al. (2001) found that 12% reported physical or sexual abuse by a partner in the past year. Among these abused women, 55.7% supported mandatory reporting, while 44.3% opposed it: 7.9% preferred that clinicians never report abuse to police and 36.4% preferred reporting only with the patient's consent. Women who had not been abused were more supportive of the laws.
More recent evidence suggests that the laws deter some survivors from seeking help. In a mixed-methods study of 2,462 survivors contacted through the National Domestic Violence Hotline, Lippy et al. (2020) found that mandatory reporting laws reduced help-seeking for more than a third of survivors, that provider warnings about reporting often kept survivors from receiving the support they sought, and that when reports were made they made the situation worse for most survivors. Experiences differed significantly by gender identity and race and ethnicity, with transgender and gender-nonconforming survivors and survivors of color facing particular risks from police involvement.
What the Laws Have Achieved
Evidence that the laws achieve their goals is weak. Sachs et al. (1998) examined 26,051 domestic violence dispatches by the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department from 1993 to 1995 and found that California's 1994 reporting law did not increase dispatches to medical facilities; total domestic violence dispatches rose after a highly publicized murder case but not after the law took effect. The study is ecological and dated, and it cannot show whether individual clinicians reported more often, but it offers no evidence that the law brought more cases from health care to police. No strong evidence shows that such laws reduce subsequent violence or homicide.
The Ethical Conflict for Nurses
For nurses, mandatory reporting of competent adults creates a conflict between legal duty and ethical obligations. The code of ethics grounds nursing practice in respect for the dignity and autonomy of each patient and in protecting patients' health and safety (American Nurses Association, 2025). A report made against a competent adult's wishes can override her own judgment about her safety, which she often knows better than anyone, and may provoke retaliation. At the same time, nurses must obey the law in their state, and a nurse who ignores a reporting statute risks legal and professional consequences. The forensic nurse cannot resolve this conflict at the bedside by disregarding the law. The appropriate responses are to practice within the law as transparently and supportively as possible and to work to change laws that the evidence suggests harm patients.
Practice Within the Law
Where reporting is mandatory, nurses can reduce harm. They can explain the reporting requirement early and honestly, before the patient discloses details she may not want reported, so that she can decide what to share. They can involve an advocate before the report is made, help the patient plan for her safety in light of the report, and document her wishes and concerns. They can also make sure that the report states only what the law requires and that the patient receives full medical care whether or not she cooperates with police.
A Policy Alternative and Advocacy Plan
The alternative supported by the evidence is consent-based reporting for competent adults: clinicians must offer to report and must provide information about advocacy and legal options, but report to police only with the patient's consent, while retaining mandatory reporting for children, adults who lack capacity and cases involving certain weapons injuries as defined by state law. This model respects the preference of the 36.4% of abused women in the Rodríguez et al. (2001) study who wanted reporting only with consent, and it avoids the deterrent effects Lippy et al. (2020) documented.
A forensic nurse advocating for this change would build a coalition with domestic violence advocacy organizations, emergency nursing and physician associations and survivor groups; gather state-specific data on how the current law affects help-seeking; prepare testimony drawing on the evidence summarized here; and propose statutory language that pairs consent-based reporting with a mandatory offer of advocacy and a warm handoff to services. The strongest argument for legislators is that survivors are more likely to seek care, and eventually to seek safety, when they control what happens to their information.
Conclusion
Mandatory reporting of adult intimate partner violence was adopted to protect victims, but the evidence suggests it may do the opposite for many of them. A large share of survivors oppose it, it deters help-seeking for more than a third, reports often worsen survivors' situations, and there is no clear evidence it increases referrals or reduces violence. Forensic nurses must follow the law where it exists while minimizing harm, and they are well placed to advocate for a consent-based model. For the woman who left with a splint and no follow-up care, such a model might have kept her in the room long enough to be helped.
References
American Nurses Association. (2025). Code of ethics for nurses. https://codeofethics.ana.org/
Lippy, C., Jumarali, S. N., Nnawulezi, N. A., Williams, E. P., & Burk, C. (2020). The impact of mandatory reporting laws on survivors of intimate partner violence: Intersectionality, help-seeking and the need for change. Journal of Family Violence, 35(3), 255-267. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10896-019-00103-w
Rodríguez, M. A., McLoughlin, E., Nah, G., & Campbell, J. C. (2001). Mandatory reporting of domestic violence injuries to the police: What do emergency department patients think? JAMA, 286(5), 580-583. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.286.5.580
Sachs, C. J., Peek, C., Baraff, L. J., & Hasselblad, V. (1998). Failure of the mandatory domestic violence reporting law to increase medical facility referral to police. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 31(4), 488-494. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0196-0644(98)70259-8
N564 Module 6 instructions, in plain terms
Aspen's N564 lists policy, law and advocacy among its forensic topics, and a Module 6 paper typically expects you to analyze a law or policy and propose advocacy. Explain the policy and its intended goals fairly. Present evidence from the people it affects. Assess whether it achieves its goals. Explain the ethical conflict for nurses with the code of ethics. Describe how nurses can practice well within the current law. Propose an alternative and an advocacy plan. Note that states differ, so describe the policy generally and identify your own state's rule, and keep the analysis balanced rather than polemical.
Inside the N564 Module 6 example
The introduction describes the patient's visit and the state's reporting rule. The purpose section lists the laws' goals: accountability, relief from the burden of reporting, a record for later cases and data. The survivor section reports Rodríguez's finding that many survivors opposed mandatory reporting and Lippy's findings that the laws deterred some from seeking care or made situations more dangerous. The outcomes section finds little evidence that the laws reduce violence. The ethics section explains the conflict between legal duty and respect for a competent adult's choices. The practice section describes telling patients about the duty before they disclose, involving advocates and safety planning. The advocacy section proposes consent-based reporting with required offers of help.
Where the marks sit in the N564 Module 6 rubric
Policy papers in N564 are judged on a fair statement of the policy, evidence on effects, ethical analysis, practical guidance and a credible advocacy plan. The laws' goals are presented sympathetically before they are questioned. Evidence includes survivors' views and outcome studies. The ethics section uses the nursing code. Practice guidance helps nurses in states where reporting is required now. The ANA's 2025 Code of Ethics, Lippy's 2020 study and Rodríguez's 2001 survey ground this mandatory reporting policy paper. The advocacy plan names a specific alternative and steps, which turns analysis into action. The advocacy plan names allies and steps, so the reader can see how the alternative might actually become law.
N564 Module 6 help: mistakes that cost marks
Policy papers often argue one side without stating the policy's goals fairly. Present them first. Another gap is relying on opinion pieces; use survivor surveys and outcome studies. Students also forget nurses who must follow the current law. Give practical guidance. State rules differ, so be precise about your own. The advocacy plan should name allies, such as advocacy coalitions and nursing associations, and steps. Keep the case composite. Avoid suggesting nurses ignore the law. Finally, distinguish adults with capacity from children and vulnerable adults, whose reporting rules rest on different reasoning. Give the exact wording you would use to tell a patient about the reporting duty before she discloses. Describe how an advocate is reached at night. Quote the reporting statute's key phrase accurately, since courts read those words closely.
Write yours, or have the desk draft it
This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.
More N564 and MSN sample papers
- N564 Module 1: Human Trafficking
- N564 Module 2: Drug-Facilitated Sexual Assault
- N564 Module 3: Asylum Forensic Evaluation
- N564 Module 4: Home Care Workplace Violence
- N564 Module 5: Violence Prevention Consultation Plan
- N564 Module 7: Nurse Expert Witness
- N564 Module 8: Compassion Fatigue and Self-Care
- N684 Module 2: Transitions of Care
- N518 Module 6: Mental Illness in the Media
- N502 Module 4: Team-Based Primary Care
- N547 Module 1: Strategic Thinking
N564 Module 6 questions, answered
What does N564 Module 6 usually ask for?
Aspen's N564 description lists policy, laws and regulation and advocacy among the forensic topics, so an analysis of a law affecting forensic patients, with a recommendation, is a typical module shape. Check your classroom for the policy and format required.
Do all states require nurses to report partner violence against adults?
No. All states require reporting of suspected child abuse, and most require reporting abuse of vulnerable or older adults, but only some require reporting injuries to competent adults from partner violence or assault. Check your own state's law.
What is consent-based reporting?
A model in which clinicians offer to report violence to police and provide information about advocacy, but report only with the competent adult patient's consent, while mandatory reporting continues for children and adults who lack capacity.
Where can I find a free N564 Module 6 sample paper?
The complete N564 Module 6 policy paper is printed above, weighing mandatory reporting of adult partner violence against survivors' views and the evidence.
Do survivors support mandatory reporting in N564 Module 6?
Many do not. Rodríguez found many survivors opposed it, and Lippy found the laws deterred some from seeking care or made their situations more dangerous.