N580 Module 1 Scholarship of Teaching Example

Reviewed by Maren Hollowell, MSN, RN Aspen University Updated September 2026

This N580 Module 1 sample paper explains the move from good teaching to scholarly teaching and on to the scholarship of teaching, beginning with a composite clinical instructor whose students knew drug facts but could not decide which medications to hold. Issues in Nursing Education is the MSN course at Aspen University that prepares nurse educators, and its first module sets the scholarship of teaching as the foundation of the role. The paper summarizes Boyer's 1990 argument in Scholarship Reconsidered that universities undervalued teaching, then separates three levels of teaching using Kreber's comparison of how experts and faculty understand the term. Glassick, Huber and Maeroff's six standards show how teaching scholarship can be judged. A section applies the idea in clinical and staff development settings and suggests a first small project.

CourseN580 Issues in Nursing Education
ModuleModule 1
Paper typeNursing education paper
LengthAbout 1,086 words, 6 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolAspen University
ProgramMSN
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for N580 Module 1

1

From Good Teaching to Scholarly Teaching: The Scholarship of Teaching and the Nurse Educator's Role

Student Name

Master of Science in Nursing Program, Aspen University

N580: Issues in Nursing Education

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this page is doingThe title marks the distinction the paper turns on, between teaching well and treating teaching as scholarship. APA 7 student title page.
2

From Good Teaching to Scholarly Teaching: The Scholarship of Teaching and the Nurse Educator's Role

For three semesters, a composite clinical instructor on a medical-surgical unit noticed that her students arrived for their first medication pass knowing drug facts but unable to decide which medications to hold. She replaced the traditional pre-clinical drug card quiz with a 20-minute case in which students reviewed a real, de-identified medication administration record and decided, with reasons, what to give and what to question. Students' performance at the bedside seemed better, and other instructors asked to borrow the case. The change was good teaching. Whether it was scholarship depends on what she did next.

The scholarship of teaching is one of the foundational ideas of nurse education, and Aspen places it at the start of this course as the basis for examining the educator's role in academic, clinical and community settings. This paper explains where the idea came from, how scholarly teaching differs from good teaching, the standards by which teaching scholarship can be judged, and how a nurse educator, including one who teaches in clinical or community settings, can demonstrate it.

What this page is doingThe opening case describes an ordinary teaching improvement and poses the paper's question about it, which keeps the theoretical discussion anchored in practice.
3

Boyer's Expanded View of Scholarship

In Scholarship Reconsidered, Boyer (1990) argued that universities had narrowed scholarship to the discovery of new knowledge through research, undervaluing other intellectual work of faculty. He proposed four related forms of scholarship. The scholarship of discovery is original research. The scholarship of integration draws on several disciplines to interpret findings and show what they mean together. Application, which later writers often call the scholarship of engagement, puts knowledge to work on to address real problems, such as a nurse's work with a community. And the scholarship of teaching treats teaching itself as a subject of serious intellectual work, in which educators study how students learn and make their findings public.

For nursing, Boyer's framework was influential because so much of nursing faculty work is teaching, much of it in clinical settings, and because nursing is a practice discipline where application is central. It gave nurse educators a way to argue that careful, studied improvement of teaching belongs in the same family as research.

What this page is doingBoyer's four forms are defined precisely from the original source, and the section explains why the framework mattered particularly to nursing, which connects theory to the discipline.
4

Good Teaching, Scholarly Teaching and the Scholarship of Teaching

Three levels are often distinguished. Good teaching is effective instruction that helps students learn. Scholarly teaching adds a deliberate, evidence-informed approach: the teacher consults the literature on learning, chooses strategies for reasons, gathers evidence about their effect and reflects on it. The scholarship of teaching goes one step further: the educator makes the work public, in a form that peers can review, critique and build on, such as a presentation, publication or peer-reviewed teaching resource.

Kreber (2003) compared conceptions of the scholarship of teaching held by experts in the field and by regular academic staff and found that the two groups did not always agree on what it involves, which helps explain why the term is used loosely in practice. The practical test is simple: if the work stays inside one classroom and one person's memory, it may be excellent teaching, but it is not yet scholarship. The instructor's medication case becomes scholarship when she frames a question about it, gathers evidence systematically, compares it with the literature and shares the results for others to judge.

What this page is doingThe three levels are separated with clear criteria, a source shows that the concept is contested, and the test is applied to the opening case, which demonstrates understanding rather than definition alone.
5

Standards for Judging Teaching Scholarship

Glassick et al. (1997), writing after Boyer, proposed six standards that apply to all forms of scholarship: clear goals, adequate preparation, fitting methods, results that matter, communication that reaches others, and critical reflection on the work. Applied to the medication case, they suggest a path. Clear goals would state what students should be able to do, such as identify medications to hold and justify the decision. Adequate preparation means reviewing the literature on teaching clinical reasoning and medication safety. Appropriate methods might compare students' decisions on a standard case before and after the new approach, or across sections that did and did not use it. Significant results are findings that matter to other educators. Effective presentation means sharing the case and findings at a conference or in a nursing education journal. Reflective critique means examining what did not work and what the instructor would change.

Nursing education has its own reasons to hold teaching to these standards. Oermann (2022) urged nurse educators to adopt educational approaches supported by evidence rather than habit, which requires that someone generate that evidence. The scholarship of teaching is how the evidence base for nursing education grows.

What this page is doingThe six standards are listed from their source and each is translated into a concrete step for the opening case, which models how an educator would actually proceed.
6

The Scholarship of Teaching in Every Setting

The educator's role extends beyond the university classroom, and so does the scholarship of teaching. A clinical instructor can study how students learn at the bedside; a staff development educator can evaluate a new orientation method; a community health educator can examine which approaches help a population learn to manage a chronic condition. The competencies expected of nurse educators include engaging in scholarship and functioning as a change agent, alongside facilitating learning and assessment (Halstead, 2019). Demonstrating the scholarship of teaching in any setting typically involves a teaching portfolio that documents questions asked, evidence gathered and changes made; peer observation and review; and dissemination through presentations, publications or shared teaching materials.

For a practicing educator, the first project need not be large. The clinical instructor in the opening case could write a one-page question, whether students who analyze a medication administration record before clinical make fewer hold-or-give errors on a standard case, gather scores from two semesters, compare them with the literature on teaching clinical reasoning and present the results at a regional nursing education conference. That modest project meets every one of the six standards. It also builds the instructor's teaching portfolio, supports promotion in academic settings and gives other instructors something better than an anecdote to decide whether to adopt the approach. Many nursing programs now offer small internal grants and mentoring for exactly this kind of work.

Conclusion

The scholarship of teaching asks nurse educators to treat their teaching as seriously as researchers treat their studies: to ask questions about student learning, gather evidence, judge it against the literature and share it for others to review. Boyer's framework gave this work legitimacy, and the standards that followed give it rigor. For the clinical instructor with the medication case, the next step is not a better case but a better question about it, pursued in a way that other educators can learn from. That step is what turns a good teacher into a scholar of teaching, and it is the foundation on which the rest of this course builds.

What this page is doingThe conclusion restates the concept and its standards and returns to the opening instructor, framing the scholarship of teaching as the basis for the course.
7

References

Boyer, E. L. (1990). Scholarship reconsidered: Priorities of the professoriate. Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching.

Glassick, C. E., Huber, M. T., & Maeroff, G. I. (1997). Scholarship assessed: Evaluation of the professoriate. Jossey-Bass.

Halstead, J. A. (Ed.). (2019). NLN core competencies for nurse educators: A decade of influence. Wolters Kluwer.

Kreber, C. (2003). The scholarship of teaching: A comparison of conceptions held by experts and regular academic staff. Higher Education, 46(1), 93-121. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1024416909866

Oermann, M. H. (2022). Adopting evidence-based educational approaches in nursing. Nurse Educator, 47(5), 259-260. https://doi.org/10.1097/NNE.0000000000001257

Reading the N580 Module 1 assignment instructions

Aspen's N580 description begins with the scholarship of teaching, so its first paper usually has you explain it and its place in the nurse educator's role. Explain Boyer's expanded view of scholarship. Distinguish good teaching, scholarly teaching and the scholarship of teaching. Explain how such work is judged. Show how it applies in clinical and staff development settings, not only universities. Use a teaching problem to make the ideas concrete. Suggest a first project a practicing educator could start. Cite Boyer directly and the NLN's educator competencies, and keep the paper focused on student learning rather than on teaching methods in general.

How this N580 Module 1 example is built

The introduction describes the instructor's observation over three semesters and frames it as the start of inquiry. The Boyer section explains his four types of scholarship and why teaching matters for nursing. The levels section distinguishes teaching well, teaching informed by the literature and making teaching public, reviewed and built on, drawing on Kreber's study. The standards section sets out Glassick and colleagues' six standards, paraphrased as clear aims, preparation, fitting methods, results that matter, effective presentation and critical reflection, and explains why nursing education should meet them. The settings section applies the idea to clinical and hospital education and proposes a small first project, such as testing a medication decision exercise and sharing results. The conclusion asks educators to treat teaching as seriously as research.

N580 Module 1 rubric: what earns full marks

Scholarship papers in N580 gain marks for an accurate account of Boyer, clear distinctions among levels of teaching, use of standards and application to real settings. Boyer is summarized from the original. The three levels are explained with a study of how faculty understand them. The six standards give the reader a way to judge scholarship rather than only define it. Application includes clinical and staff development settings. Boyer's 1990 report, Glassick, Huber and Maeroff's 1997 book and Halstead's 2019 edition of the NLN core competencies underpin this scholarship of teaching paper. The opening problem returns in the first project, which ties the paper together.

N580 Module 1 help: mistakes that cost marks

Papers in this module often summarize Boyer at length and never reach the educator's practice. Apply the ideas. Another gap is treating good teaching and the scholarship of teaching as the same thing. Explain what makes teaching scholarly and public. Students also forget clinical and staff development settings. Include them. Use the standards to show how work would be judged. Suggest a project small enough to start this term. Keep the instructor example composite. Cite the NLN competencies. Finally, connect the scholarship of teaching to student learning outcomes, since that is the purpose of the work. Name the outcome you would measure in your first project, such as accuracy on a medication decision exercise. Share results with colleagues before seeking publication, since local peer review is also scholarship.

Write yours, or have the desk draft it

This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.

More N580 and MSN sample papers

N580 Module 1 questions, answered

What does N580 Module 1 usually ask for?

Aspen's N580 description begins with the scholarship of teaching as the foundation of the nurse educator's role, so an opening paper explaining the concept and applying it to a setting is a typical first assignment. Check your classroom for the exact prompt.

What are Boyer's four types of scholarship?

Discovery, integration, application (or engagement) and teaching. Boyer argued that all four are legitimate forms of academic scholarship, not only original research.

How is scholarly teaching different from the scholarship of teaching?

Scholarly teaching is evidence-informed and reflective. The scholarship of teaching adds systematic inquiry into student learning and makes the results public so peers can review and build on them.

Where can I find a free N580 Module 1 sample paper?

The full N580 Module 1 paper is above, explaining Boyer's scholarship of teaching and how a nurse educator moves from good teaching to scholarly work.

How does teaching become scholarship in N580 Module 1?

By moving past teaching well to teaching informed by the literature, and then to making that teaching public so peers can review and build on it, the levels the paper draws from Kreber's study.