DNP850 Module 3 Practice Scholarship vs Research Paper Example

Reviewed by Maren Hollowell, MSN, RN Aspen University Updated October 2026

This DNP850 Module 3 sample paper asks the same question about heart failure follow-up twice, once as a clinic improvement project and once as a multi-site trial, to show how practice scholarship differs from generalizable research. Aspen University's DNP program uses the third module of Nursing Practice, Professionalism, and Scholarship to settle a question every DNP student hears: is my project research? The paper places both versions in Boyer's four forms of scholarship, then applies the Hastings Center criteria for deciding when improvement work needs research review. It contrasts SQUIRE 2.0 reporting with trial reporting, explains what rigor means for a project built on repeated measurement, and defends both forms as necessary to the profession rather than ranking one above the other.

CourseDNP850 Nursing Practice, Professionalism, and Scholarship
ModuleModule 3
Paper typeScholarship paper
LengthAbout 1,055 words, 6 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolAspen University
ProgramDNP
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DNP850 Module 3

1

Improving Here or Knowing Everywhere: Distinguishing Practice Scholarship From Generalizable Research, and Why Nursing Needs Both

Student Name

Doctor of Nursing Practice Program, Aspen University

DNP850: Nursing Practice, Professionalism, and Scholarship

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this page is doingThe title states the core distinction in plain words, local improvement versus generalizable knowledge, and signals that the paper will defend both. APA 7 student title page for a doctoral program.
2

Improving Here or Knowing Everywhere: Distinguishing Practice Scholarship From Generalizable Research, and Why Nursing Needs Both

DNP students are often told that their projects are not research, a statement that can sound like a demotion. It is better understood as a distinction between two forms of scholarship with different purposes, methods, and ethical requirements. This paper uses Boyer's model of scholarship to describe that distinction, applies it to a single question about follow-up after hospital discharge, explains how the purpose of a project determines whether it requires research review, and defends the value of both forms.

What this page is doingThe introduction addresses a common misunderstanding and states the paper's approach, framework and defense.
3

Boyer's Model of Scholarship

Boyer (1990) argued that academic scholarship had been defined too narrowly as research and proposed four interrelated forms. The scholarship of discovery is the pursuit of new knowledge through research. The scholarship of integration makes connections across disciplines and places findings in larger context. The scholarship of application, sometimes called engagement, applies knowledge to consequential problems and allows practice itself to generate new understanding. The scholarship of teaching transforms and extends knowledge through education. Nursing adopted this model to recognize that the practice-focused work of the DNP is scholarship, primarily of application and integration, while the PhD centers on discovery.

What this page is doingBoyer's four forms are defined accurately with the source, and nursing's use of the model to position the DNP is explained.
4

One Question, Two Forms

Consider a single concern: patients discharged after heart failure hospitalization often miss early follow-up. The question can be asked in two ways.

As practice scholarship: Can our clinic increase the proportion of heart failure patients seen within 7 days of discharge by scheduling appointments before discharge and offering telehealth visits? The aim is improvement in this setting. The design is iterative: small tests of change, each studied and adjusted, with the follow-up rate plotted monthly against a baseline. The knowledge produced is local and practical, although it may be shared so others can adapt it.

As generalizable research: Does a nurse-led transitional care intervention reduce 30-day readmissions compared with usual care among patients discharged after heart failure hospitalization? The aim is knowledge that applies beyond the study sites. The design might be a randomized trial across several hospitals, with a prespecified hypothesis, sample size calculation, control group, and statistical analysis. The difference is not in the topic but in the purpose: one asks what will work here, the other what is true in general.

What this page is doingThe same topic is framed two ways with aims, designs and types of knowledge, making the distinction concrete. The highlighted sentence captures the essential difference.
5

Why the Distinction Matters Ethically

The distinction has practical consequences for review. Scholars and clinical leaders brought together to examine the ethics of improvement work described it as the ordinary business of delivering care well: structured, measured efforts to make care better, now, in a particular place. Because of that, they argued, clinicians and patients share a duty to take part, and the bulk of such work is not research on human subjects. Its oversight belongs with the people who already supervise clinical practice, scaled to its risk, rather than with a research ethics board. They also acknowledged a middle ground of projects that are partly both and suggested sorting projects by their features and context (Lynn et al., 2007).

For the clinic project, the purpose is local improvement, the intervention is consistent with accepted practice, patients are not randomized, and the data are those already collected in care. It is quality improvement, and the organization's QI review process applies, though many universities still require DNP students to submit a determination request to confirm that status. The multi-site trial randomizes patients, tests a hypothesis, and aims to generalize, so it requires institutional review board approval and, in most cases, informed consent. Treating a trial as QI to avoid review would violate research ethics; treating every QI project as research would slow improvement without protecting anyone.

What this page is doingThe ethics section uses an authoritative report accurately, applies its criteria to both versions of the question and states the consequences of misclassification in either direction.
6

Reporting Each Form

The two forms are also reported differently. Research is reported with conventions such as CONSORT for trials, emphasizing the control of bias and the precision of effect estimates. Improvement work is reported with the SQUIRE 2.0 guidelines, which require an account of the problem as it appeared locally, the setting's particular features, what was changed and how the change evolved, and how its effects were studied and measured, so that readers can judge whether and how the change might work elsewhere (Ogrinc et al., 2016). The emphasis on context in SQUIRE reflects the scholarship of application: what worked depended on where it happened.

What this page is doingDistinct reporting standards illustrate how the two forms differ in what counts as a rigorous account, tying the distinction to publication practice.
7

Rigor in Practice Scholarship

Calling a project quality improvement does not lower the standard of rigor; it changes what rigor means. In the clinic project, rigor means a clearly defined measure, the proportion of heart failure discharges seen within 7 days, with the numerator and denominator specified; a baseline long enough to show normal variation; run or control charts that distinguish real change from noise; documentation of each change and when it began, so that shifts in the data can be linked to specific actions; and attention to balancing measures, such as whether telehealth visits displace in-person visits for patients who need an examination. It also means honesty about limits. Without a control group, a rise in follow-up could reflect a new hospital discharge policy or seasonal variation rather than the project. A rigorous improvement report names such alternative explanations and explains why the evidence favors the project's effect, or admits that it cannot. These are the standards DNP projects should be judged by.

What this page is doingThe section explains what rigor means in improvement work, with specific methods and an honest account of limits, which answers the implication that practice scholarship is less rigorous.
8

Defending Both

Nursing needs both forms. Without discovery, practice would have no tested interventions to apply; the transitional care models DNP projects implement came from trials. Without application, discoveries would sit in journals while patients continued to miss follow-up. Practice scholarship also feeds discovery: when many clinics report improvement projects with their context, patterns emerge that suggest new research questions, such as why telehealth follow-up works in some populations and not others. The central point of Boyer's model was that these forms are equally legitimate and interdependent (Boyer, 1990). The DNP's work is not lesser research; it is a different and necessary scholarship.

What this page is doingThe defense shows interdependence in both directions and returns to Boyer's central claim, completing the argument.
9

Conclusion

Practice scholarship and generalizable research differ in purpose, design, ethical review, and reporting, not in rigor or importance. Asking the same question about post-discharge follow-up in both forms shows that the DNP project's aim, improvement in a particular setting, is what makes it quality improvement and what makes it valuable. Understanding the distinction allows DNP-prepared nurses to design projects correctly, seek the right review, report them well, and work alongside nurse scientists whose discoveries they bring into practice.

What this page is doingThe conclusion lists the dimensions of difference and the practical benefits of understanding them.
10

References

Boyer, E. L. (1990). Scholarship reconsidered: Priorities of the professoriate. Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching.

Lynn, J., Baily, M. A., Bottrell, M., Jennings, B., Levine, R. J., Davidoff, F., Casarett, D., Corrigan, J., Fox, E., Wynia, M. K., Agich, G. J., O'Kane, M., Speroff, T., Schyve, P., Batalden, P., Tunis, S., Berlinger, N., Cronenwett, L., Fitzmaurice, J. M., ... James, B. (2007). The ethics of using quality improvement methods in health care. Annals of Internal Medicine, 146(9), 666-673. https://doi.org/10.7326/0003-4819-146-9-200705010-00155

Ogrinc, G., Davies, L., Goodman, D., Batalden, P., Davidoff, F., & Stevens, D. (2016). SQUIRE 2.0 (Standards for QUality Improvement Reporting Excellence): Revised publication guidelines from a detailed consensus process. BMJ Quality & Safety, 25(12), 986-992. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjqs-2015-004411

Reading the DNP850 Module 3 assignment instructions

Aspen's DNP850 Module 3 often asks you to distinguish practice scholarship from research and to explain why the difference matters. Use a single topic for both forms so the contrast is fair. State the aim, design, setting and kind of knowledge each version would produce. Place each in a recognized model of scholarship such as Boyer's. Address ethics: explain when improvement work must go to an IRB and when it may proceed without one, citing a source. Describe how each form is reported. Explain what rigor means in improvement work, since readers may assume it is lower. End by defending both forms. Keep the clinic composite, and avoid suggesting that a DNP project is lesser because it is not designed to generalize.

How this DNP850 Module 3 example is built

The introduction takes on the idea that calling a DNP project not research is a demotion. Boyer's section defines discovery, integration, application and teaching and shows how nursing used the model to place the DNP. The two-forms section frames heart failure follow-up first as a local project with monthly data and then as a randomized trial across sites. The ethics section draws on the Hastings Center report to show where review is needed and what goes wrong when a project is misclassified. The reporting section sets SQUIRE 2.0 against trial conventions. The rigor section names measures, run charts and honest limits. The defense section shows each form feeding the other, and the conclusion lists the differences in purpose, design, review and reporting.

Where the marks sit in the DNP850 Module 3 rubric

Distinction papers in DNP850 earn credit for accurate definitions, one topic framed both ways, an ethical analysis grounded in a source and a fair defense of both forms. Here the heart failure question carries the whole comparison, which keeps the argument concrete. Boyer's 1990 Carnegie report supplies the framework. Lynn and colleagues' 2007 Hastings Center report in the Annals of Internal Medicine sets the ethics of improvement work, and Ogrinc and colleagues' 2016 SQUIRE 2.0 guideline anchors the reporting section. The rigor section matters to graders because it answers the unstated doubt about improvement projects. A paper that treats research as superior, or improvement as exempt from all oversight, would lose marks; this one avoids both errors.

Common DNP850 Module 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them

A weak version of this paper explains research on one page and quality improvement on the next, with no shared example. Run both through one question. Another frequent gap is claiming that improvement projects never need review. Cite criteria and apply them. Students also mix up reporting guidelines; SQUIRE is for improvement and CONSORT for trials. Explain rigor in improvement work with specifics, such as measurement plans and run charts, rather than reassurance. Avoid ranking the two forms. Show how a trial informs practice and how practice raises questions for research. Name Boyer's four forms accurately. Close by stating which form your own project will take and why, since the course will hold you to that choice later in the program.

Write yours, or have the desk draft it

This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.

More DNP850 and DNP sample papers

DNP850 Module 3 questions, answered

What does DNP850 Module 3 usually ask for?

The module often asks you to distinguish practice scholarship, such as quality improvement, from generalizable research and to explain the value of each. Aspen does not publish module deliverables, so your classroom's instructions govern.

What are Boyer's four forms of scholarship?

Discovery, the pursuit of new knowledge through research; integration, connecting findings across disciplines; application or engagement, applying knowledge to real problems; and teaching, transforming knowledge through education.

Does a DNP quality improvement project need IRB review?

Most quality improvement is not human subjects research and is overseen through professional and organizational review, but projects that randomize patients or aim to produce generalizable knowledge require IRB review. Many universities ask DNP students to obtain a formal determination.

Where can I find a free DNP850 Module 3 sample paper?

The full DNP850 Module 3 paper is above, framing heart failure follow-up as a clinic project and as a trial to separate practice scholarship from research.

Is a DNP project research or quality improvement?

Most DNP projects are improvement work meant to change care in one setting. The example applies the Hastings Center criteria to show when such a project still needs ethics review.