DNP860 Module 5 Improvement Model Selection Paper Example

Reviewed by Maren Hollowell, MSN, RN Aspen University Updated October 2026

This DNP860 Module 5 sample paper explains why plan-do-study-act cycles under the Model for Improvement won out against Lean and Six Sigma as the way to frame a blood culture collection bundle in a composite emergency department. Aspen University's Evidence-Based Practice for Quality Improvement asks DNP students in Module 5 to select an improvement model and defend the choice. Five criteria guide the decision: fit with uneven evidence on the bundle's parts, the team's training, speed of learning, available data and support in the literature. Each model is described from its sources, Langley's improvement guide for the first, with DelliFraine's review of Lean and Six Sigma and Taylor's review of PDSA use for the rest. The paper then sets an aim of under 2 percent in nine months and names team roles.

CourseDNP860 Evidence-Based Practice for Quality Improvement
ModuleModule 5
Paper typeModel selection paper
LengthAbout 1,053 words, 6 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolAspen University
ProgramDNP
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DNP860 Module 5

1

Small Tests Over Big Rollouts: Why the Model for Improvement Beat Lean and Six Sigma as the Frame for a Blood Culture Collection Bundle

Student Name

Doctor of Nursing Practice Program, Aspen University

DNP860: Evidence-Based Practice for Quality Improvement

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this page is doingThe title states the choice and the alternatives rejected, and signals the principle, testing on a small scale, that drove the decision. APA 7 student title page for a doctoral program.
2

Small Tests Over Big Rollouts: Why the Model for Improvement Beat Lean and Six Sigma as the Frame for a Blood Culture Collection Bundle

An improvement model gives a project its structure: how problems are defined, how changes are designed and tested, and how success is judged. Choosing one deliberately matters, because models differ in what they emphasize and what they demand of a team. This paper states criteria for selecting a model for the emergency department blood culture contamination project, compares three widely used approaches, the Model for Improvement, Lean, and Six Sigma, and justifies the choice of the Model for Improvement.

What this page is doingThe introduction explains why model choice matters and names the alternatives and the conclusion, which frames a reasoned selection.
3

Selection Criteria

Five criteria guided the choice. First, fit with the evidence: the appraisal found good evidence for each bundle component individually but none for the three together, so the model must allow components to be introduced and evaluated in sequence. Second, fit with the setting: a community emergency department with high turnover and no dedicated improvement staff. Third, speed of learning: the team wants early signals rather than waiting months for a full analysis. Fourth, data demands: the model must work with monthly contamination data from the laboratory. Fifth, evidence of effectiveness for the model itself in health care.

What this page is doingCriteria are derived from the appraisal findings and the setting, which ties the model choice to the project's evidence and context.
4

The Model for Improvement

The Model for Improvement opens with three questions that fix the aim, the measures that will show progress, and the ideas worth testing. It then tests changes through plan-do-study-act cycles, each of which states in advance what the team expects, tries the change on a small scale, compares what happened with what was expected, and decides what to do next (Langley et al., 2009). Tests begin small, such as one nurse on one shift, and grow as confidence increases.

The model fits the criteria well. It allows each bundle component to be tested separately and in sequence. It requires no specialized statistical training, which suits a team without improvement staff. Small cycles produce early learning. It works with run charts of monthly or weekly data. Its main weakness lies in how it is often applied rather than in the model itself. A systematic review of 73 articles reporting the use of plan-do-study-act cycles found that fewer than 20 percent fully documented a sequence of iterative cycles and only 15 percent of those analyzed let data gathered at least once a month steer them from one cycle to the next (Taylor et al., 2014). The model works when its discipline is kept; the risk is calling a single rollout a cycle.

What this page is doingThe model is described accurately with its source, evaluated against each criterion, and its known weakness in application is reported from a systematic review. The highlighted sentence identifies the risk the project must manage.
5

Lean

Lean focuses on eliminating waste and improving flow by mapping the value stream, identifying steps that do not add value for the patient, and redesigning processes around the work. It would be useful for mapping how blood culture collection fits into the emergency department's flow, for example to reduce the time nurses spend gathering supplies for sterile collection. But its emphasis is on efficiency and flow rather than on reducing a specific defect, and a full value stream analysis would require facilitation expertise the department lacks. Lean tools, such as standardized work and supply kits at the point of care, can be borrowed within the Model for Improvement.

What this page is doingLean is described fairly, its partial usefulness is acknowledged and its tools are integrated rather than rejected outright.
6

Six Sigma

Six Sigma aims to reduce variation and defects through the DMAIC cycle, define, measure, analyze, improve, and control, using statistical tools to identify root causes. Blood culture contamination is a defect with a clear rate, which makes Six Sigma attractive in principle. However, it typically requires trained belts, extensive baseline measurement, and statistical analysis before changes are made, which would slow the project and exceed the team's resources. Its evidence base in health care is also limited: a review of 177 articles on Six Sigma and Lean in health care found that only 34 reported any outcomes and fewer than a third of those included statistical tests of change, concluding that evidence that these approaches improve quality was very weak (DelliFraine et al., 2010).

What this page is doingSix Sigma's appeal for defect reduction is acknowledged, and it is set aside for resource and evidence reasons, reported accurately from a review.
7

The Decision

The Model for Improvement best meets the criteria. It supports sequential testing of the bundle's components, suits a team without specialized training, produces early learning, works with available data, and, although evidence about improvement models in general is limited, it is the most widely used and documented approach in health care. Lean tools will be borrowed for standardizing supplies, and the Six Sigma emphasis on defining the defect precisely has already shaped the definition of contamination used in the project.

What this page is doingThe decision is justified against every criterion and integrates useful elements of the alternatives, which reflects mature judgment.
8

What the Choice Commits the Project To

Choosing the Model for Improvement commits the team to its discipline. The aim will be stated with a number and a date: reduce contamination from 4.1 percent to below 2 percent within nine months. Each cycle will start with a written prediction and end with a documented decision to adopt, adapt, or abandon the change. The first cycle will test separate venipuncture with one nurse on day shift for one week; later cycles will add sterile technique and then diversion, expanding by shift and pod. Data will be plotted on run charts weekly. These commitments address the weaknesses the review of plan-do-study-act use identified.

What this page is doingThe section translates the choice into concrete commitments, including an aim, predictions and a cycle sequence, which directly counters the documented weaknesses in PDSA use.
9

Team Roles Within the Model

The model also shapes who does what. The DNP student will serve as improvement lead, responsible for keeping the cycle log, the run charts, and the discipline of predictions. Two emergency nurses, a day-shift and a night-shift colleague, will design and run each test on their shifts, because a change designed by the nurses who will carry it out tends to fit the realities of a busy shift. The microbiology supervisor will provide weekly contamination data by collector and method, and the infection preventionist will review each cycle's results with the team. The emergency department nurse manager will sponsor the project, protect time for the team's 30-minute weekly meeting, and remove barriers such as supply shortages. Writing these roles down at the start prevents the common pattern in which the improvement lead ends up running every test alone.

What this page is doingSpecifying roles under the chosen model shows how the model's structure translates into a working team.
10

Conclusion

The Model for Improvement was selected over Lean and Six Sigma because it allows the bundle's components to be tested in sequence, suits a team without specialized training, and produces early learning from available data. Its known weakness, loose application, will be managed by committing to documented predictions, iterative cycles, and frequent data. Tools from the other approaches will be used where they help.

What this page is doingThe conclusion restates the choice, its reasons and how its weakness will be managed.
11

References

DelliFraine, J. L., Langabeer, J. R., & Nembhard, I. M. (2010). Assessing the evidence of Six Sigma and Lean in the health care industry. Quality Management in Health Care, 19(3), 211-225. https://doi.org/10.1097/QMH.0b013e3181eb140e

Langley, G. J., Moen, R. D., Nolan, K. M., Nolan, T. W., Norman, C. L., & Provost, L. P. (2009). The improvement guide: A practical approach to enhancing organizational performance (2nd ed.). Jossey-Bass.

Taylor, M. J., McNicholas, C., Nicolay, C., Darzi, A., Bell, D., & Reed, J. E. (2014). Systematic review of the application of the plan-do-study-act method to improve quality in healthcare. BMJ Quality & Safety, 23(4), 290-298. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjqs-2013-001862

What the DNP860 Module 5 instructions ask for

In Aspen's DNP860, Module 5 often asks you to select an improvement model for your project and justify it against alternatives. Set criteria first, based on your evidence, team and data. Describe each candidate model accurately, including its tools and what it demands of a team. Apply each to your project and judge it against your criteria. Choose one and explain what the choice commits you to, such as aims, predictions and measures. Admit where the chosen model tends to go wrong and say what will prevent that here. Describe team roles within the model. Use sources on the models themselves and on their evidence in health care, and be honest where that evidence is thin, since graders reward accuracy over enthusiasm.

Inside the DNP860 Module 5 example

The introduction explains that a model gives a project its structure. The criteria section sets five standards, starting with the appraisal's finding that the bundle's parts have separate evidence. The Model for Improvement section describes its three questions and plan-do-study-act cycles. The Lean section credits value stream mapping and explains why waste reduction is not the main problem. The Six Sigma section notes that contamination is a clear defect but that the method needs trained belts and large data sets. The decision section scores each model. The commitment section sets the aim of under 2 percent within nine months and requires written predictions for each cycle. The team section assigns the student, two emergency nurses and a laboratory partner their parts.

DNP860 Module 5 rubric: what earns full marks

Model selection papers in DNP860 earn the most credit for explicit criteria, accurate descriptions, fair comparison, a justified choice and awareness of weaknesses. This example sets criteria from its own evidence appraisal, which ties the choice to the project rather than to preference. Langley and colleagues' 2009 Improvement Guide describes the chosen model. DelliFraine, Langabeer and Nembhard's 2010 review in Quality Management in Health Care reports limited evidence for Lean and Six Sigma, and Taylor and colleagues' 2014 review in BMJ Quality and Safety shows that PDSA is often applied loosely. Naming that weakness, then committing to predictions and cycle logs, is the judgment graders look for at the doctoral level.

DNP860 Module 5 help from the desk

Selection papers often describe three models and pick one in a sentence. Score them against criteria. Another frequent gap is describing Lean and Six Sigma as identical; explain the difference between waste and variation. Students also overstate evidence for their chosen model. Report what the reviews found, including weaknesses. Say what the choice commits you to, such as a numeric target and a deadline. Assign team roles. Avoid choosing a model your team cannot use without specialized training. Keep the department composite. Finally, show how the chosen model fits the evidence you appraised in the previous module, so the course reads as one continuous argument rather than separate assignments.

Write yours, or have the desk draft it

This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.

More DNP860 and DNP sample papers

DNP860 Module 5 questions, answered

What does DNP860 Module 5 usually ask for?

The module usually asks you to select an improvement model for your project, such as the Model for Improvement, Lean or Six Sigma, and justify the choice against alternatives. Aspen does not publish module deliverables, so your classroom's instructions govern.

What are the three questions of the Model for Improvement?

The questions ask what the team wants to achieve, how it will measure whether a change helped, and which changes are worth testing. Each change is then tried through plan-do-study-act cycles.

What is the difference between Lean and Six Sigma?

Lean focuses on eliminating waste and improving flow, while Six Sigma focuses on reducing variation and defects through the define, measure, analyze, improve and control cycle using statistical tools.

Where can I find a free DNP860 Module 5 sample paper?

The complete DNP860 Module 5 paper is above, explaining why PDSA cycles beat Lean and Six Sigma as the frame for a blood culture collection bundle.

Why does DNP860 Module 5 pick PDSA cycles instead of Six Sigma?

It lets the bundle's three components be tested one at a time, suits a team without specialized training and gives early learning from data the laboratory already collects.