| Course | DNP870 Health Policy, Advocacy, and Partnerships |
|---|---|
| Module | Module 5 |
| Paper type | Stakeholder map |
| Length | About 1,022 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Aspen University |
| Program | DNP |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DNP870 Module 5
Follow the Testimony and the Money: A Stakeholder Map for a State Community Health Worker Coverage Bill
Student Name
Doctor of Nursing Practice Program, Aspen University
DNP870: Health Policy, Advocacy, and Partnerships
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Follow the Testimony and the Money: A Stakeholder Map for a State Community Health Worker Coverage Bill
Advocates often know who supports their bill. They know less about who opposes it, why, and who pays for that opposition. A policy stakeholder map that includes funding helps advocates anticipate arguments, find potential allies among opponents, and understand the resources arrayed against them. This paper maps stakeholders for a composite state bill to cover community health worker services under Medicaid, using public testimony, lobbying registrations, and campaign finance disclosures.
Method
Varvasovszky and Brugha (2000) describe stakeholder analysis as a way to understand a policy by identifying the actors involved, their interests, their influence, and their positions, and they caution that analysts must be explicit about their own position and sources. This map drew on four public sources: written and oral testimony at the committee hearing; the state's lobbyist registration database, which lists clients and bills lobbied; lobbying expenditure reports filed quarterly; and campaign contribution records for members of the two committees that heard the bill. Each stakeholder was classified by position, influence, and resources. Where a group's position was unclear from the record, the map lists it as undecided rather than guessing, and the gap becomes a task for the next round of meetings.
Supporters
Supporters included the state nurses association, the community health worker association, the association of federally qualified health centers, two regional hospital systems, the state public health association, and several patient and anti-poverty organizations. Their interests vary: nurses and health centers see a way to address social needs they encounter daily, hospitals see potential reductions in avoidable readmissions, and community health worker organizations seek stable funding and professional recognition. Their influence is moderate: the nurses association and hospital systems have registered lobbyists and relationships with legislators, while community groups bring constituents and stories. The evidence base supports their position; a trial of community health worker support found fewer hospital days, and an analysis estimated a return of $2.47 per dollar to Medicaid (Kangovi et al., 2020).
Opponents
Opposition came from three sources. The state association of Medicaid managed care plans testified against the bill as written, arguing that a mandated fee-for-service benefit would reduce plans' flexibility. The state's business and taxpayer federation submitted written testimony opposing new Medicaid spending. And the state association of licensed social workers raised concerns about overlap between community health worker services and social work scope, seeking clear boundaries rather than outright defeat.
Who Funds the Opposition
Disclosure records show that the managed care association reported the largest lobbying expenditure on health bills in the session and employed two contract lobbyists; its members are the four plans holding Medicaid contracts, whose revenue depends on state capitation rates. The business and taxpayer federation is funded by member companies and reported spending on a general budget campaign rather than this bill specifically; several committee members received contributions from its political committee in the last election. The social workers' association has no paid lobbyist and relies on volunteer members. The loudest opposition was not the best funded, and the best funded opposition was the most negotiable. The managed care plans' objection was to the payment mechanism, not to community health workers themselves; several plans already fund small community health worker programs.
Neutral and Undecided Stakeholders
The Medicaid agency testified neutrally, raising implementation concerns about certification and timelines. The governor's budget office did not testify but signaled concern about cost. The state medical society took no position. These actors have substantial influence on whether the bill is funded and implemented, and their concerns can be addressed through amendments, such as a pilot structure and delayed effective date.
Comparing the Coalitions' Resources
Influence depends on resources, and the two sides hold different kinds. The opposition's advantage is money and access: paid lobbyists who meet legislators throughout the session, and campaign contributions that keep doors open. The supporters' advantage is numbers, credibility, and stories. The nurses association can mobilize members in every legislative district; community health workers and patients can describe what the work changes; and hospital systems carry weight with legislators whose districts depend on them as employers. Nurses are consistently rated among the most trusted professions, which gives their testimony a credibility that paid lobbyists lack. The supporters' task is to convert those assets into sustained contact with the members who will decide, especially the chairs of the health and appropriations committees and the members who received contributions from the opposition's political committee. A single hearing is not enough; the opposition's lobbyists will be in the building every week of the session.
Strategic Implications
The map suggests three strategies. First, negotiate with the managed care plans by letting them purchase services from community-based worker programs and credit that spending toward their quality incentive targets, turning the best-funded opponent into a partial ally. Second, address the social workers' concern with statutory language defining community health worker services as distinct from clinical social work and requiring referral pathways. Third, answer the fiscal opposition with a pilot limited in scope and cost, an evaluation requirement, and data on savings. Longest (2016) emphasizes that policy is shaped through interaction among interest groups, legislators, and agencies; understanding each group's interests, not only its position, opens room for negotiation.
Keeping the Map Current
Stakeholder positions change during a session. The map will be updated after each committee action, each quarterly lobbying report, and any public statement by a major actor. If the managed care plans accept the contracting amendment, they move from opponent to neutral or supporter; if the budget office's concerns harden, the pilot's scope may need to shrink further. A map that is not revised becomes a record of where things stood, not a guide to where they are going.
Conclusion
Mapping stakeholders by position, influence, and funding reveals that opposition to the community health worker bill is neither uniform nor fixed. The best-funded opponent objects to a mechanism, not a goal; another seeks boundaries, not defeat; and fiscal concerns can be met with a pilot. Following both the testimony and the money gives advocates a clearer picture of whom to persuade and how.
References
Kangovi, S., Mitra, N., Grande, D., Long, J. A., & Asch, D. A. (2020). Evidence-based community health worker program addresses unmet social needs and generates positive return on investment. Health Affairs, 39(2), 207-213. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2019.00981
Longest, B. B., Jr. (2016). Health policymaking in the United States (6th ed.). Health Administration Press.
Varvasovszky, Z., & Brugha, R. (2000). How to do (or not to do) . . . A stakeholder analysis. Health Policy and Planning, 15(3), 338-345. https://doi.org/10.1093/heapol/15.3.338
What the DNP870 Module 5 instructions ask for
Module 5 of Aspen's DNP870 frequently asks you to map stakeholders on a policy, including who funds the opposition. Explain your method and your own position, since the analyst is a stakeholder too. List supporters, opponents and neutral actors with what each wants. Use public records, such as testimony, lobbying disclosures and campaign finance reports, to show who pays for opposition. Separate stated positions from underlying interests. Compare the resources each side holds. Turn the map into strategies, such as negotiating with an opponent whose objection is about a mechanism. Plan how the map will be updated. Keep the state composite, and describe funding from records a student could actually consult rather than guesses about motive.
Inside the DNP870 Module 5 example
The introduction explains that advocates know their supporters better than their opponents. The method section applies Varvasovszky and Brugha and states the writer's position. The supporters section lists nurses, community health workers, health centers, hospitals, public health and patient groups. The opponents section explains the managed care association's objection to a fee-for-service mandate, the business federation's concern about cost and the specialty group's worry about scope. The funding section reports lobbying expenditures and contract lobbyists from disclosure records. The neutral section covers the Medicaid agency, the budget office and the medical society. The resources section compares money and access with numbers and credibility. Three strategies follow, and the updating section ties revisions to committee actions and quarterly lobbying reports.
Reading the DNP870 Module 5 grading rubric
A DNP870 stakeholder map is marked for its method, how fully it identifies actors, its funding evidence, how it separates positions from interests and the strategies it yields. This example earns credit by using disclosure records to show who pays for opposition, which is what this module adds to an ordinary stakeholder list. Varvasovszky and Brugha's 2000 guide in Health Policy and Planning supplies the method, Longest's 2016 text explains interest groups and Kangovi and colleagues' 2020 study is the evidence supporters bring. The insight that the best-funded opponent objects to a mechanism rather than the goal shows graders analysis rather than description, and it produces the strongest strategy in the paper.
Common DNP870 Module 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Stakeholder maps often list supporters at length and opponents in a line. Spend as much effort on opposition. Another common gap is guessing at motives; use testimony and disclosure records. Students also treat opponents as fixed. Separate position from interest and look for room to negotiate. Include neutral actors with power, such as the budget office. Compare resources honestly. Turn the map into strategies. State your own position. Keep the state composite. Avoid accusing named real organizations. Record the date of every disclosure report you cite. Finally, explain when the map will be updated, because positions shift during a session and a map drawn in January can mislead by April.
Write yours, or have the desk draft it
This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.
More DNP870 and DNP sample papers
- DNP870 Module 1: Bill Through Committee Paper
- DNP870 Module 2: Legislation Versus Regulation Paper
- DNP870 Module 3: Health Policy Analysis Paper
- DNP870 Module 4: Policy Options Analysis
- DNP870 Module 6: Professional Organization Advocacy Discussion
- DNP870 Module 7: Legislative Testimony
- DNP870 Module 8: Advocacy Plan
- DNP860 Module 7: Evaluation Plan Paper
- DNP845 Module 6: Borrowed Theory Discussion
- DNP 850A Module 4: Needs Assessment of the Project Site
- DNP 851A Module 8: Implementation Report
DNP870 Module 5 questions, answered
What does DNP870 Module 5 usually ask for?
The module usually asks you to map the stakeholders for a health policy, including opponents and the groups that fund them, and to consider what the map means for advocacy. Aspen does not publish module deliverables, so your classroom's instructions govern.
How can I find out who funds opposition to a bill?
Public sources include state lobbyist registration databases, lobbying expenditure reports, campaign contribution records and testimony at hearings, which together show who is lobbying, for whom and with what resources.
Why distinguish an opponent's position from its interests?
A group may oppose a bill as written while sharing its goal. Understanding the interest behind the position, such as flexibility for managed care plans, can reveal amendments that turn opponents into partial allies.
Where can I find a free DNP870 Module 5 sample paper?
The complete DNP870 Module 5 paper is above, mapping supporters, opponents and neutral actors on a community health worker bill and the funding behind the opposition.
How do I find who funds opposition for a DNP870 stakeholder map?
Use public records: committee testimony, state lobbying disclosure reports and campaign finance filings. The example finds the managed care association reported the largest health lobbying spending of the session.