N494 Module 2 Quantitative Study Appraisal Example

Reviewed by Maren Hollowell, MSN, RN Aspen University Updated October 2026

This N494 Module 2 sample paper critically appraises one randomized trial from the course search: April and colleagues' 2018 comparison of inhaled isopropyl alcohol with oral ondansetron for emergency department nausea. The second module of Aspen University's Essentials of Nursing Research teaches RN to BSN students to judge quantitative evidence, and this paper uses the three appraisal questions from Melnyk and Fineout-Overholt. It places the blinded, placebo-controlled trial at Level II, weighs features that support validity against ones that limit it, including whether a saline placebo can be truly blinded when alcohol has a smell, and reports mean nausea reductions of 30, 32 and 9 millimeters. It judges the difference clinically meaningful and asks whether results apply to the composite fast-track area from Module 1.

CourseN494 Essentials of Nursing Research
ModuleModule 2
Paper typeQuantitative critical appraisal
LengthAbout 1,023 words, 6 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolAspen University
ProgramRN to BSN
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for N494 Module 2

1

Can a Placebo Smell Like Nothing? A Critical Appraisal of a Randomized Trial Comparing Inhaled Isopropyl Alcohol With Oral Ondansetron

Student Name

RN to BSN Program, Aspen University

N494: Essentials of Nursing Research

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this page is doingThe title leads with the appraisal's most interesting question, whether blinding can hold when one treatment has a strong smell, which signals that this will be a critical appraisal rather than a summary. The second half names the study precisely. APA 7 student title page.
2

Can a Placebo Smell Like Nothing? A Critical Appraisal of a Randomized Trial Comparing Inhaled Isopropyl Alcohol With Oral Ondansetron

Critical appraisal asks three questions of a study: are the results valid, what are the results, and will they help in caring for my patients (Melnyk & Fineout-Overholt, 2023). This paper applies those questions to a randomized controlled trial retrieved in the literature search for the Module 1 clinical question, which asks whether inhaled isopropyl alcohol relieves nausea in emergency department adults faster than oral ondansetron or placebo within half an hour. The trial, by April et al. (2018), compared inhaled isopropyl alcohol with oral ondansetron in 122 adult emergency department patients.

What this page is doingThe introduction names the appraisal framework and ties the study to the student's own PICOT question, which shows continuity across the course. Stating the three appraisal questions at the outset gives the paper its structure.
3

Study Overview and Level of Evidence

The study is a randomized, blinded, placebo-controlled trial conducted in the emergency department of an urban tertiary care hospital. Adults with nausea or vomiting who did not need immediate intravenous access were randomly assigned to one of three arms: inhaled isopropyl alcohol plus 4 mg oral ondansetron, inhaled isopropyl alcohol plus an oral placebo, or inhaled saline placebo plus 4 mg oral ondansetron. The primary outcome was the change in nausea on a 0 to 100 mm visual analog scale from enrollment to 30 minutes. Secondary outcomes were the use of rescue antiemetic medication and adverse events (April et al., 2018).

As a single randomized controlled trial, the study represents Level II evidence in a common hierarchy, below systematic reviews of randomized trials and above nonrandomized and observational designs (Melnyk & Fineout-Overholt, 2023). Its design is well suited to an intervention question because randomization, when done well, balances known and unknown factors between groups, so differences in outcome can be attributed to the intervention.

What this page is doingThe overview describes design, setting, arms, primary and secondary outcomes accurately, then places the study in the evidence hierarchy and explains why randomization matters. That answers the prompt's overview questions about study type and level before appraisal begins.
4

Are the Results Valid?

Several features support validity. Participants were randomized, the trial used placebos to allow blinding, and follow-up was nearly complete: 120 of 122 enrolled participants (98.3 percent) finished the study, so attrition is unlikely to have biased the results (April et al., 2018). The outcome measure, a visual analog scale for nausea, is widely used and has been validated for this purpose, and the 30-minute time point matches the clinical need for rapid relief.

Other features limit confidence. Participants were a convenience sample enrolled when research staff were available, which may not represent all patients who present with nausea. The study took place at a single center, and patients who needed intravenous access were excluded, so the findings apply to less severely ill patients. The most important concern is blinding. Isopropyl alcohol has a distinctive smell, while inhaled saline has none, so participants could likely tell which inhaled treatment they received. When patients can guess their assignment, a subjective outcome such as nausea severity is vulnerable to expectation effects, and the design cannot fully separate the effect of the alcohol from the effect of believing one has received an active treatment. The authors used an oral placebo so that ondansetron was blinded, but the inhaled comparison could not be truly masked.

What this page is doingThis is the core of the appraisal, and it weighs strengths and weaknesses rather than listing features. The blinding problem is identified and explained in terms of how it could bias a subjective outcome, which demonstrates genuine critical thinking about this particular design.
5

What Are the Results?

Nausea scores fell by a mean of 30 mm in the isopropyl alcohol plus ondansetron arm, 32 mm in the isopropyl alcohol plus placebo arm, and 9 mm in the saline plus ondansetron arm. The 95 percent confidence intervals for the two isopropyl alcohol arms (22 to 37 mm and 25 to 39 mm) did not overlap with the interval for the ondansetron-only arm (5 to 14 mm), indicating a clear difference. Fewer patients in the isopropyl alcohol arms needed rescue antiemetics (27.5 percent and 25.0 percent) than in the ondansetron-only arm (45.0 percent) (April et al., 2018).

The size of the difference is clinically meaningful as well as statistically significant: a reduction of more than 20 mm on a 100 mm scale is a change patients would notice. The finding that adding ondansetron to isopropyl alcohol did not improve relief at 30 minutes is also informative. It may reflect the fact that oral ondansetron takes time to be absorbed, so a 30-minute window favors a fast-acting inhaled treatment.

The findings are consistent with an earlier trial by the same research group. That double-blind trial enrolled 84 patients, 80 of whom finished, and found that ten minutes after inhalation began, the median nausea rating stood at three points in the alcohol group against six in the saline group; later use of rescue antiemetics, however, did not differ between groups (Beadle et al., 2016). The earlier trial measured relief at 10 minutes and the later one at 30, so together they suggest the effect begins quickly and is still present half an hour later. Consistency across two trials strengthens confidence that the effect is real, but both were conducted by overlapping investigators at similar military teaching hospitals, so independent replication in other emergency departments would add weight.

What this page is doingResults are reported with effect sizes, confidence intervals and the secondary outcome, and the paper distinguishes statistical from clinical significance. Interpreting the null result for combined therapy in light of oral ondansetron's absorption time shows the writer reads results critically rather than accepting them at face value.
6

Will the Results Help in Caring for Patients?

The results are relevant to the composite fast-track area described in Module 1. The study population, adults with nausea not needing immediate intravenous access, closely matches the fast-track population. The intervention is inexpensive, already stocked, and simple enough to offer at triage under a nursing protocol, and the trial reported few adverse events. The main cautions are that the effect was measured over 30 minutes only, so it does not show whether relief lasts, and that the blinding concern means some of the benefit may reflect expectation. For a low-risk, low-cost intervention offered while patients wait for evaluation, that uncertainty is less concerning than it would be for a costly or risky treatment.

What this page is doingThe applicability section compares the study population with the student's own setting, weighs benefits against the identified limitations and considers the intervention's low risk. That judgment, not just a yes or no, is what the third appraisal question asks for.
7

Conclusion

This randomized trial provides Level II evidence that inhaled isopropyl alcohol reduces nausea within 30 minutes more than oral ondansetron alone in adult emergency department patients who do not need intravenous access. Its strengths include randomization, near-complete follow-up, and a clinically meaningful effect; its weaknesses include a convenience sample, a single site, a short outcome window, and a blinding problem inherent in comparing a scented treatment with an unscented placebo. On its own the study is not enough to change practice, but it is a strong piece of the evidence that will be synthesized, with the systematic reviews found in the search, in later modules.

What this page is doingThe conclusion balances strengths and weaknesses and places the study within the larger body of evidence, which is exactly where a single-study appraisal should end. It avoids overclaiming and points to the next step, synthesis.
8

References

April, M. D., Oliver, J. J., Davis, W. T., Ong, D., Simon, E. M., Ng, P. C., & Hunter, C. J. (2018). Aromatherapy versus oral ondansetron for antiemetic therapy among adult emergency department patients: A randomized controlled trial. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 72(2), 184-193. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.annemergmed.2018.01.016

Beadle, K. L., Helbling, A. R., Love, S. L., April, M. D., & Hunter, C. J. (2016). Isopropyl alcohol nasal inhalation for nausea in the emergency department: A randomized controlled trial. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 68(1), 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.annemergmed.2015.09.031

Melnyk, B. M., & Fineout-Overholt, E. (2023). Evidence-based practice in nursing & healthcare: A guide to best practice (5th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.

What the N494 Module 2 instructions ask for

Aspen's N494 Module 2 has you appraise one quantitative study drawn from your Module 1 search, organized around validity, results and usefulness for patient care. The classroom names any required appraisal tool and the length. Summarize the study's design, setting and sample briefly. Identify its level of evidence with a named hierarchy. Judge validity by naming specific strengths and specific threats, and explain how each threat could bias the result. Report the results with numbers and judge whether they matter clinically, not only statistically. Then judge whether the results would hold for the people you care for. Keep the appraisal tied to your PICOT question, so the paper reads as the next step of one project rather than a standalone review.

How the N494 Module 2 example is put together

The introduction states the three appraisal questions. The overview describes a randomized, blinded, placebo-controlled trial in an urban tertiary emergency department with three arms and places it at Level II. The validity section lists randomization, blinding and a prespecified outcome as strengths, then names limits, including the difficulty of blinding an intervention people can smell and the single-site sample. The results section reports mean reductions of 30 millimeters for alcohol plus ondansetron, 32 for alcohol plus placebo and 9 for saline plus ondansetron, and explains why a change over 20 millimeters is one patients notice. It notes agreement with Beadle's earlier trial. The usefulness section applies the findings to the fast-track area, and the conclusion states what the trial supports.

Where the marks sit in the N494 Module 2 rubric

Quantitative appraisals get credit for accuracy of the study summary, depth of the validity analysis, interpretation of results, applicability and APA writing. The validity marks come from explaining how a specific design feature could bias a specific outcome, which is the clearest sign of critical thinking. Results are reported with numbers and judged for clinical meaning. Applicability is tied to a defined setting rather than claimed in general. April's 2018 Annals of Emergency Medicine trial, Beadle's 2016 trial and the Melnyk and Fineout-Overholt text for the appraisal framework anchor the N494 paper's claims. The conclusion states the level of evidence and what the trial can and cannot tell a nurse deciding on practice.

N494 Module 2 help from the desk

Appraisals often turn into summaries of the article with a sentence of praise at the end. Spend most of your words judging, not describing. Another frequent problem is listing threats to validity without saying how they would change the result. A p value alone, with no effect size, leaves the reader unable to judge clinical meaning. State the difference in the outcome's own units. Avoid the word proof; one trial adds to the evidence without settling it. Check that the level you assign matches your course's hierarchy. If the study has a placebo arm, ask whether the placebo could be distinguished. Finally, keep your applicability section realistic about who in your setting would and would not qualify.

Write yours, or have the desk draft it

This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.

More N494 and RN to BSN sample papers

N494 Module 2 questions, answered

What does N494 Module 2 usually ask for?

Commonly a critical appraisal of one quantitative research study from your literature search: the study type, where it falls in the hierarchy of evidence, how reliable it is and its risk of bias, and whether the results apply to your practice. Your classroom's rubric sets the exact questions and length.

What are the three critical appraisal questions?

Are the results valid, what are the results, and will they help in caring for my patients. The sample uses them as section headings, which makes it easy for a grader to see that each has been answered.

How do I show critical thinking in an appraisal?

Explain how a specific design feature could bias the specific outcome. The sample shows that because isopropyl alcohol has a smell and saline does not, patients could guess their group, which matters for a subjective outcome like nausea. General statements such as 'the sample was small' earn less credit.

Where can I find a free N494 Module 2 sample paper?

The complete N494 Module 2 appraisal is above, judging a randomized emergency department trial of inhaled isopropyl alcohol for validity, results and use in practice.

What is the difference between statistical and clinical significance in N494?

A result can pass a significance test and still be trivial; clinical significance asks whether patients would notice the change or practice ought to shift.