| Course | DNP865 Healthcare Technologies and Informatics |
|---|---|
| Module | Module 5 |
| Paper type | System selection paper |
| Length | About 1,073 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Aspen University |
| Program | DNP |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DNP865 Module 5
From Pagers to Smartphones: Selecting a Clinical Communication Platform Against Weighted Criteria, With the Case Against Two Alternatives
Student Name
Doctor of Nursing Practice Program, Aspen University
DNP865: Healthcare Technologies and Informatics
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
From Pagers to Smartphones: Selecting a Clinical Communication Platform Against Weighted Criteria, With the Case Against Two Alternatives
Selecting a clinical information system is a decision with years of consequences, and it should be made against criteria defined before vendors are compared. This paper selects a clinical communication platform for a composite 260-bed hospital that still relies on pagers, overhead paging, and unsecured personal text messages. It defines weighted criteria, scores three options, argues for the selected option, and explains why the others were rejected.
The Problem
Nurses at the hospital reach physicians by numeric pagers and wait for callbacks, a median of 14 minutes on nights according to a two-week log. Alarms from cardiac monitors and nurse call lights reach nurses only through hallway displays and overhead announcements. Some staff use personal phones to text colleagues, sending patient information through channels that are neither secure nor recorded. A secure, integrated communication system is needed.
Criteria and Weights
Six criteria were defined with the selection committee of nurses, physicians, informatics staff, and the security officer, and weighted by importance. Usability, 25 percent: whether nurses and physicians can send, receive, and act on messages quickly in real conditions. Following the TURF framework's three dimensions of usability, usefulness for the work, ease of use, and user satisfaction, all three were tested in simulated scenarios (Zhang & Walji, 2011). Integration, 25 percent: whether the platform connects to the electronic health record, nurse call system, and physiologic monitors, so that alarms and patient context reach the right phone. Security and compliance, 20 percent: encryption, device management, message retention, and audit trails. Reliability, 10 percent: coverage throughout the building and downtime procedures. Cost, 10 percent: five-year total cost of ownership. Vendor support, 10 percent: implementation services and references from similar hospitals.
A case study of a health system's evaluation of secure messaging applications stratified 19 vendors into tiers, from basic secure messaging, to messaging within an existing clinical application, to dedicated communication and collaboration systems, and found that security and communication functions were essential while advanced features were secondary (Liu et al., 2019). The hospital's criteria follow the same logic.
The Options
Option A is the secure messaging module offered by the hospital's electronic health record vendor, running on hospital-issued smartphones. Option B is a dedicated clinical communication and collaboration platform from a specialist vendor, also on hospital-issued smartphones, with integration to the electronic health record, nurse call, and monitors. Option C is an upgrade of the existing paging system to two-way alphanumeric pagers with a secure texting gateway, keeping overhead paging for emergencies.
Scoring
Using a five-point scale, committee members scored each option on each criterion after demonstrations, simulated scenarios with 20 nurses and 8 physicians, and reference calls. Option A scored 3 on integration overall, strong with the electronic health record but weak with nurse call and monitors, along with 3 on usability, 4 on security, 4 on reliability, 4 on cost, and 4 on support, for a weighted total of 3.50. Option B scored 5 on integration, 4 on usability, 4 on security, 4 on reliability, 2 on cost, and 4 on support, for a weighted total of 4.05. Option C scored 1 on integration, 2 on usability, 3 on security, 5 on reliability, 5 on cost, and 3 on support, for a weighted total of 2.65. The cheapest option scored lowest, and the option that cost most scored highest, because the criteria weighted what nurses need to do their work, not what the budget prefers.
The Case for Option B
Option B is recommended because it best meets the two most heavily weighted criteria. Its integration routes monitor alarms and nurse call lights directly to the assigned nurse's phone with patient context, which addresses the hospital's dependence on hallway displays and overhead announcements. In simulated scenarios, nurses completed a physician consultation, from message to reply, faster than with the other options, and physicians rated its interface the easiest. Adoption also depends on how users perceive a system: a review of the technology acceptance model in health care concluded that how useful and how easy clinicians judge a technology to be accounts for a substantial share of whether they accept and use it (Holden & Karsh, 2010). Option B scored highest on both in the post-scenario survey.
The Case Against Option A
Option A's close connection to the electronic health record is a real advantage, and its cost is lower. It was rejected because it does not integrate with the hospital's nurse call and monitor systems, so alarms would continue to rely on hallway displays, the problem nurses rated most important. Its interface for group messaging and escalation was also less usable in simulation. If the vendor adds alarm integration in the future, the decision should be revisited.
The Case Against Option C
Option C is the least expensive and most reliable, since pagers work where cellular and wireless signals do not. It was rejected because it preserves one-way, context-free communication, does not integrate with alarms or the record, and would not end the use of personal phones, since staff would still lack a convenient secure alternative. Its reliability advantage will be preserved in the recommended design by keeping a small number of pagers for downtime and for areas with poor coverage.
Sensitivity of the Decision
Because weights involve judgment, the committee tested whether the recommendation depended on them. If cost were weighted at 25 percent instead of 10, with usability and integration reduced to 17.5 percent each, Option B would still lead, at 3.68 against 3.65 for Option A and 3.18 for Option C, although its margin would nearly vanish. That result shows the decision rests on how much weight integration and usability deserve, which the committee judged the right priority for a system nurses will use every hour. The committee also agreed on conditions that would reopen the decision: a failed pilot on two units, a security review that found unacceptable risks, or a price increase of more than 15 percent before contract signing.
Conclusion
Selecting a clinical communication platform against weighted criteria defined in advance led to a clear recommendation: a dedicated platform that integrates alarms, nurse call, and the electronic health record on hospital-issued smartphones. Its higher cost is justified by its performance on the criteria that matter most for nurses and patients, and the reasons the alternatives were rejected are documented so the decision can be reviewed if circumstances change.
References
Holden, R. J., & Karsh, B.-T. (2010). The technology acceptance model: Its past and its future in health care. Journal of Biomedical Informatics, 43(1), 159-172. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbi.2009.07.002
Liu, X., Sutton, P., McKenna, R., Sinanan, M., Fellner, B., Leu, M., & Ewell, C. (2019). Evaluation of secure messaging applications for a health care system: A case study. Applied Clinical Informatics, 10(1), 140-150. https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0039-1678607
Zhang, J., & Walji, M. F. (2011). TURF: Toward a unified framework of EHR usability. Journal of Biomedical Informatics, 44(6), 1056-1067. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbi.2011.08.005
DNP865 Module 5 instructions, in plain terms
Module 5 in Aspen's DNP865 often asks you to select a clinical information system and defend the choice against alternatives. State the problem with local data. Agree on criteria and their weights with frontline nurses and physicians before any vendor demonstration. Describe each option fairly. Explain how you scored them, using demonstrations, simulations or reference calls. Show the scores. Make the case for your choice and a separate case against each rejected option, crediting their strengths. Test whether the decision depends on the weights. Use sources on technology acceptance or usability. Keep the hospital and vendors composite, and avoid naming real products, since the assignment is about the method of selection rather than a product review.
Inside the DNP865 Module 5 example
The introduction argues that selection should follow criteria defined in advance. The problem section gives the 14-minute night callback and the hallway alarm displays. The criteria section lists six weighted criteria agreed with nurses, physicians, informatics staff and the security officer. The options section describes the record vendor's module, a dedicated platform and upgraded pagers. The scoring section explains the five-point scale and the scenarios used. The recommendation section rests on integration with alarms and nurse call. Separate sections give the case against the vendor module, strong with the record but weak on alarms, and against pagers, reliable but one-way. The sensitivity section shows the dedicated platform still leads when cost is weighted higher, and the conclusion states the choice.
DNP865 Module 5 rubric: what earns full marks
Selection papers in DNP865 are graded on criteria defined before comparison, fair descriptions, transparent scoring, a reasoned choice, a real case against alternatives and attention to uncertainty. This example earns credit for the sensitivity test, which shows the recommendation holds when cost is weighted more heavily, though narrowly. Holden and Karsh's 2010 review of the technology acceptance model frames why usability is weighted highest. Liu and colleagues' 2019 case study in Applied Clinical Informatics shows how secure messaging tools are evaluated, and Zhang and Walji's 2011 TURF framework supports the usability scoring. Crediting the rejected options' strengths, such as pager reliability, shows graders a balanced judgment rather than advocacy.
Common DNP865 Module 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Selection papers often pick a system first and invent criteria to fit. Set criteria and weights before scoring. Another frequent gap is a one-line dismissal of alternatives; give each a fair case. Students also present scores without saying how they were produced. Describe demonstrations and scenarios. Test the weights, since a small change can reverse a close decision. Include security and cost, even if weighted lower. Use a usability or acceptance framework. Keep vendors composite. Avoid overstating benefits; say what the chosen platform will not fix. Finally, state what must be true for the choice to succeed, such as wireless coverage in every room, because those conditions become the go-live plan in the next module.
Write yours, or have the desk draft it
This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.
More DNP865 and DNP sample papers
- DNP865 Module 1: Data to Knowledge Paper
- DNP865 Module 2: Interoperability Failure Analysis
- DNP865 Module 3: Documentation Workflow Map
- DNP865 Module 4: Decision Support and Alert Fatigue Paper
- DNP865 Module 6: Ethical Data Use Discussion
- DNP865 Module 7: Go-Live Plan
- DNP865 Module 8: Informatics Governance Recommendation
- DNP 851A Module 2: Educating the Staff Who Deliver It
- DNP 852B Module 1: A Dissemination Plan by Audience
- DNP 835 Module 2: Critique of a Health Care Leadership Role
- DNP 810 Module 5: Methodology and Data Collection Plan
DNP865 Module 5 questions, answered
What does DNP865 Module 5 usually ask for?
The module usually asks you to select a health information system or technology against defined criteria, explaining the choice and why alternatives were rejected. Aspen does not publish module deliverables, so your classroom's instructions govern.
How should criteria for selecting a clinical system be weighted?
Weights should reflect what matters most to the users and patients the system serves, agreed by a multidisciplinary committee before vendors are compared, so that the scoring cannot be shaped to favor a preferred option.
What is the technology acceptance model?
A theory that users' acceptance and use of technology depend largely on its perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use. A review found it predicts a substantial portion of clinicians' use of health IT.
Where can I find a free DNP865 Module 5 sample paper?
The full DNP865 Module 5 paper is above, selecting a clinical communication platform over a record vendor module and upgraded pagers with weighted criteria.
How should I weight criteria in a DNP865 system selection paper?
Settle the weights with nurses, physicians and IT before any demonstration. The example weights usability and integration highest, then tests whether the choice changes when cost counts more.