N520 Module 1 Ethical Issues Case Responses Example

Reviewed by Maren Hollowell, MSN, RN Aspen University Updated October 2026

This N520 Module 1 sample paper answers three ethics prompts: a dispute over care that clinicians believe is medically inappropriate, the three wrongful actions in reproductive law, and the stem cell research controversy. Legal and Ethical Issues in Health Care is the MSN course at Aspen University built on Guido's textbook, and its first module tests ethical decision-making. Part one walks a composite case, in which a patient's sons demand full treatment, through each step of Guido's MORAL model. It uses Bosslet's multisociety statement to separate futile from potentially inappropriate treatment and sets out the nurse's actions, from requesting a family meeting to involving palliative care. Part two distinguishes wrongful birth, wrongful life and wrongful conception by who sues and for what. Part three weighs the embryonic stem cell debate and shifting federal policy.

CourseN520 Legal and Ethical Issues in Health Care
ModuleModule 1
Paper typeCase response paper
LengthAbout 1,073 words, 6 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolAspen University
ProgramMSN
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for N520 Module 1

1

When Care Appears Medically Inappropriate: The MORAL Model, the Three Wrongful Actions, and the Stem Cell Debate

Student Name

Master of Science in Nursing Program, Aspen University

N520: Legal and Ethical Issues in Health Care

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this page is doingThe title names the three parts of the combined response in the order they appear, so the grader can map each answer to the prompt. APA 7 student title page.
2

When Care Appears Medically Inappropriate: The MORAL Model, the Three Wrongful Actions, and the Stem Cell Debate

This paper answers the Module 1 prompts in three parts. Part 1 applies Guido's MORAL model to a composite case in which a family demands treatment the team believes will not help. Part 2 distinguishes wrongful birth, wrongful life, and wrongful conception. Part 3 summarizes the controversy over stem cell research and where it stands today.

What this page is doingA combined-response document benefits from a short roadmap that tells the grader where each answer sits.
3

Part 1: The MORAL Model Applied

The composite case: Mr. W., 84, has been in the intensive care unit for three weeks with septic shock, kidney failure requiring dialysis, and respiratory failure. He has no advance directive. His condition has worsened despite maximal therapy, and the team believes that cardiopulmonary resuscitation would not restore him to any condition he would value. His two sons insist that "everything" be done, including resuscitation, and say their father "never gave up on anything." The nurses caring for him are distressed by what they describe as prolonging his dying.

Guido's MORAL model provides five steps for ethical decision-making (Guido, 2020).

What this page is doingThe case is summarized with the facts that create the dilemma: no directive, worsening condition despite treatment, family demands and staff distress.
4

M: Massage the Dilemma

The dilemma sets respect for the patient's presumed wishes, expressed through his sons as surrogates, against the clinicians' duty not to impose burdensome treatment without benefit. The principles in tension are autonomy, beneficence, and nonmaleficence (Beauchamp & Childress, 2019). The stakeholders are Mr. W., whose own values are the ethical center of the case; his sons; the physicians and nurses; and the institution. The key question is not what the team prefers, but what Mr. W. would want and what treatment can realistically achieve.

What this page is doingThe first step identifies the principles in conflict, the stakeholders and the central question, which is the analytic foundation the rest of the model depends on.
5

O: Outline the Options

The options are to continue all treatment including resuscitation as the sons request; to have the attending physician enter a do-not-resuscitate order unilaterally; to continue current treatment while seeking agreement through structured communication; or to follow a formal process for potentially inappropriate treatment. Each option carries consequences for Mr. W.'s comfort, the family's trust, staff moral distress, and the institution's legal exposure.

What this page is doingThe options range from full agreement with the family to unilateral action, with consequences named for each, which shows balanced reasoning.
6

R: Resolve the Dilemma

A multisociety policy statement recommends reserving the word futile for interventions that cannot accomplish their intended physiologic goal and using potentially inappropriate for treatments that have some chance of an effect but that clinicians believe are not justified by competing ethical considerations (Bosslet et al., 2015). Because resuscitation might briefly restore circulation, it falls into the potentially inappropriate category, and the statement recommends a fair process rather than a unilateral decision: expert consultation, a second medical opinion, review by an interdisciplinary committee, an offer to transfer care to another clinician or institution, and notice to surrogates of their right to seek outside review.

The resolution is therefore procedural: the team neither yields to the demand nor overrides it alone, but follows a process that protects both the patient and the family's standing. I would first pursue a family meeting with palliative care to explore what "never giving up" meant to Mr. W. and what he would say about his present condition.

What this page is doingThe resolution applies a named policy statement accurately, including the distinction between futile and potentially inappropriate treatment. The highlighted sentence states why a procedural answer is ethically stronger than either extreme.
7

A: Act by Applying the Chosen Option

The nurse's actions include requesting the family meeting and a palliative care consultation, attending the meeting to share observations about Mr. W.'s comfort, documenting the discussion, and requesting an ethics consultation if disagreement continues. Throughout, the nurse continues full nursing care and supports the sons, whose grief may be driving their demands.

What this page is doingAction steps are specific to the nurse's role and include continued care and family support, which shows the model is being applied rather than recited.
8

L: Look Back and Evaluate

The final step asks whether the outcome respected Mr. W.'s values and whether the process was fair. The team should review whether earlier conversations about goals of care might have prevented the conflict, and nurses who experienced moral distress should be offered a debriefing. Lessons learned can inform a unit protocol for early goals-of-care discussions.

What this page is doingEvaluation looks at both the outcome and the process and ends in a systems improvement, which completes the model.
9

Part 2: Wrongful Birth, Wrongful Life, and Wrongful Conception

These three actions arise when negligence is alleged in reproductive care, and they differ in who sues and what injury is claimed (Guido, 2020). Wrongful birth is brought by parents who allege that a provider's negligence, such as failing to offer or correctly interpret prenatal genetic testing, deprived them of the information they needed to decide whether to continue a pregnancy, and that a child was born with a serious condition as a result. Many states recognize this claim, usually allowing recovery of the extraordinary costs of caring for the child.

Wrongful life is brought on behalf of the child, who claims that but for the negligence they would not have been born. Most courts reject these claims because they would require comparing life with a disability to never having existed, although a few states allow recovery of special damages such as medical expenses. Wrongful conception, also called wrongful pregnancy, is brought by parents after a negligent sterilization or contraceptive failure leads to an unplanned pregnancy, usually of a healthy child; damages are typically limited to the costs of the pregnancy and the failed procedure.

What this page is doingEach action is defined by plaintiff, alleged negligence and recognized damages, and the general judicial treatment is stated accurately, which answers the distinction the prompt requires.
10

Part 3: The Stem Cell Research Controversy

The controversy centers on embryonic stem cells, which can become any cell type and therefore hold promise for treating diseases such as diabetes, spinal cord injury, and Parkinson's disease. Obtaining them destroys the embryo, so the debate turns on the moral status of the embryo. Those who hold that an embryo has the moral status of a person oppose the research as the taking of a human life; supporters argue that early embryos, particularly those left over from in vitro fertilization and otherwise discarded, do not have that status and that the potential to relieve suffering justifies their use.

Federal policy has shifted with these arguments, with funding limited to existing embryonic stem cell lines in 2001 and expanded in 2009. The development of induced pluripotent stem cells, adult cells reprogrammed to an embryonic-like state, has reduced but not eliminated the controversy, since these cells avoid embryo destruction but remain less understood. For nurses, the ethical skill is to understand both positions well enough to support patients whose religious or moral views shape their decisions about research participation or treatment.

What this page is doingThe stem cell section presents both positions fairly, notes policy changes and the scientific development that reshaped the debate, and ends with a nursing application.
11

Conclusion

The MORAL model turns a painful conflict into a structured process that respects the patient's values, the family's role, and the clinicians' integrity. The three wrongful actions show how negligence in reproductive care is defined by who is harmed and how, and the stem cell debate shows how moral disagreement shapes science and policy. In each case, the nurse's task is to reason clearly, respect differing values, and act within professional and legal duties.

What this page is doingThe conclusion connects the three parts through the common skill of structured ethical reasoning.
12

References

Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2019). Principles of biomedical ethics (8th ed.). Oxford University Press.

Bosslet, G. T., Pope, T. M., Rubenfeld, G. D., Lo, B., Truog, R. D., Rushton, C. H., Curtis, J. R., Ford, D. W., Osborne, M., Misak, C., Au, D. H., Azoulay, E., Brody, B., Fahy, B. G., Hall, J. B., Kesecioglu, J., Kon, A. A., Lindell, K. O., & White, D. B. (2015). An official ATS/AACN/ACCP/ESICM/SCCM policy statement: Responding to requests for potentially inappropriate treatments in intensive care units. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 191(11), 1318-1330. https://doi.org/10.1164/rccm.201505-0924ST

Guido, G. W. (2020). Legal and ethical issues in nursing (7th ed.). Pearson.

What the N520 Module 1 instructions ask for

Aspen's N520 opens with combined responses to the ethics chapters of Guido's Legal and Ethical Issues in Nursing, usually including a case worked through the MORAL model and short answers on other topics. Your classroom lists the exact prompts. Use the model's five steps as headings and fill each with case facts, not definitions. Name the options before choosing one. Support the resolution with a principle and a recognized policy statement. Describe what the nurse actually does. Evaluate the outcome. For legal distinctions, say who brings the action and what injury is claimed. For a controversy, give both positions fairly and note where policy stands, citing the textbook and at least one source beyond it.

How the N520 Module 1 example is put together

A short introduction lists the three parts. Part one introduces the composite patient and his sons' demands. Massage the dilemma sets the surrogates' voice against the duty not to impose burdensome treatment. Outline the options lists four choices, from continuing everything to a formal process for disputed treatment. Resolve the dilemma uses Bosslet's statement on the words futile and potentially inappropriate and chooses structured communication with a formal process if needed. Act describes the nurse requesting a family meeting and a palliative care consult and sharing observations. Look back asks whether the outcome respected the patient. Part two explains the three wrongful actions in turn. Part three explains why embryonic cells raise ethical objections and how federal funding rules have shifted.

Reading the N520 Module 1 grading rubric

Combined response papers in N520 are scored prompt by prompt, so each part must answer its own question fully. The MORAL section is strongest because every step uses case facts and the resolution rests on a multisociety statement rather than opinion. The nurse's role is concrete. The wrongful actions are distinguished by plaintiff and injury, the two points graders look for. The stem cell section presents both sides and current policy without taking a polemical tone. Bosslet's 2015 multisociety policy statement, Guido's seventh edition and the principles text by Beauchamp and Childress support the analysis. The conclusion ties the three parts to structured ethical reasoning.

Common N520 Module 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Students often recite the MORAL steps with definitions and never apply them. Fill every step with the case. Another gap is choosing the resolution before outlining options, which defeats the model. Using the word futile loosely also costs marks; follow the multisociety distinction. The wrongful actions are easily confused, so build a sentence for each with who sues and what they claim. In the stem cell part, avoid arguing only one side. Keep legal statements general unless you cite your state's law. Cite Guido for definitions and add one outside source for each part. Finally, label each part clearly so the grader can match answers to prompts.

Write yours, or have the desk draft it

This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.

More N520 and MSN sample papers

N520 Module 1 questions, answered

What does N520 Module 1 usually ask for?

A Word document of combined responses on the ethics chapters of Guido's textbook, including applying the MORAL model to a scenario about care that appears medically inappropriate, distinguishing wrongful birth, wrongful life and wrongful conception, and discussing the stem cell research controversy.

What are the steps of Guido's MORAL model?

Massage the dilemma, Outline the options, Resolve the dilemma, Act by applying the chosen option and Look back and evaluate the process and outcome.

What is the difference between wrongful birth and wrongful life?

Wrongful birth is brought by parents who claim negligence denied them information to decide about a pregnancy; many states allow it. Wrongful life is brought on behalf of the child, claiming they would not have been born; most courts reject it.

Where can I find a free N520 Module 1 sample paper?

The full N520 Module 1 paper is above, working a treatment dispute through the MORAL model and answering the wrongful actions and stem cell prompts.

What dilemma does the N520 Module 1 paper resolve?

Sons demanding full treatment for their father against the duty not to impose burdensome care. The paper lists four options and uses Bosslet's statement on potentially inappropriate treatment.