| Course | DNP870 Health Policy, Advocacy, and Partnerships |
|---|---|
| Module | Module 1 |
| Paper type | Legislative process paper |
| Length | About 1,017 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Aspen University |
| Program | DNP |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DNP870 Module 1
Where Bills Live or Die: Tracing a State Community Health Worker Coverage Bill Through Committee
Student Name
Doctor of Nursing Practice Program, Aspen University
DNP870: Health Policy, Advocacy, and Partnerships
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Where Bills Live or Die: Tracing a State Community Health Worker Coverage Bill Through Committee
Nurses who want to influence health policy need to know how a bill actually becomes law, and especially where it is most likely to stall. Textbook diagrams show a straight line from introduction to signature. In practice, most of the important decisions happen in committee, and a bill's fate often depends on its fiscal note. This paper traces a composite state bill that would require Medicaid to pay for community health worker services through each stage, identifying the decision points where nurses can intervene.
The Bill and Its Rationale
House Bill 1142 in a composite state, the Community Health Worker Services Coverage Act, would direct the state Medicaid agency to cover services provided by certified community health workers, such as help with housing, transportation, food, and navigating care, when recommended by a licensed practitioner. The evidence behind it is strong for a policy proposal. In a randomized trial of 592 low-income patients across primary care facilities, patients paired with community health workers accumulated 155 hospital days over six months against 345 in the comparison group, and were more likely to report the highest quality of care (Kangovi et al., 2018). A later analysis put the return at $2.47 for every dollar a typical Medicaid payer invests, realized within a single fiscal year (Kangovi et al., 2020).
Stage 1: Drafting and Introduction
The bill was drafted by the legislature's nonpartisan drafting office at the request of a representative who sits on the House committee responsible for health bills, after meetings with the state nurses association and a coalition of community health worker organizations. Drafting choices mattered: specifying certification standards and a practitioner recommendation addressed concerns about quality and billing, and a delayed effective date gave the Medicaid agency time to prepare. The sponsor recruited cosponsors from both parties before introduction. On first reading, the Speaker sent the bill to the House committee on health and human services.
Stage 2: Committee Hearing
Committee is where most bills end; many are never scheduled for a hearing at all. Longest (2016) describes the legislative phase of policy formulation as the stage in which proposals are shaped through hearings, negotiation, and amendment, with committees and their chairs exercising substantial control over which proposals advance. The sponsor's first task was persuading the chair to schedule a hearing, which she did after the nurses association arranged meetings with two committee members from the chair's party.
At the hearing, testimony came from a community health worker, a patient, a primary care nurse practitioner, the Medicaid director, and a managed care organization representative. Supporters emphasized hospital days avoided and return on investment. The Medicaid director raised concerns about administrative cost and the timeline for certification. The managed care representative asked that plans be allowed to contract with community health worker organizations rather than pay individual workers.
Stage 3: Markup and Amendments
At markup, the committee adopted two amendments responding to testimony: one allowing managed care plans to contract with community health worker organizations, and one delaying the effective date by six months to give the Medicaid agency time for certification rules. Each amendment cost the bill a little of its original shape and bought it a vote. The committee voted 9 to 4 to report the bill favorably as amended.
Stage 4: The Fiscal Note and Appropriations
Because the bill required new Medicaid spending, the legislature's fiscal office prepared a fiscal note estimating its cost. The first estimate projected $14 million in annual state and federal spending, without counting savings, because the office's rules counted only direct costs. Supporters asked the office to consider offsetting savings from reduced hospital use; the revised note included a range of possible savings but described them as uncertain. The bill was then referred to the Appropriations Committee, a common destination for bills with costs and a place where many die for lack of funds. There, the sponsor negotiated a two-year pilot limited to three regions, reducing the first-year cost to $4 million, and the committee reported the bill favorably.
The fiscal stage also shows why evidence must be translated into the terms a budget office uses. A trial result expressed as hospital days avoided persuades clinicians; a fiscal analyst needs dollars, a timeframe, and a source. Supporters who arrived with a one-page estimate of avoided Medicaid hospital spending, drawn from the published return on investment and the state's own admission costs, were able to shape the revised note in a way that general statements about better care could not.
Stage 5: Floor, Second Chamber, and Governor
The House passed the amended bill 71 to 27. In the Senate, it repeated the process in the Health Committee and Finance Committee, where a senator added a requirement for an evaluation report to the legislature after the pilot. Because the Senate version differed, the House concurred in the Senate amendment rather than going to a conference committee. The governor, whose budget office had supported the pilot version, signed the bill. The statute then passed to the Medicaid agency, whose regulations and state plan amendment will determine how the program actually works, the subject of the next module.
Where Nurses Can Intervene
The trace reveals five points where nurses can change the outcome: shaping the bill before introduction, persuading the chair to schedule a hearing, giving concise testimony grounded in evidence and experience, providing data that influence the fiscal note, and negotiating amendments that answer opponents' concerns without destroying the bill's purpose. At each point, nurses bring credibility with legislators and firsthand knowledge of patients' unmet social needs. They also bring numbers: the admissions, emergency visits, and missed appointments they see every week can be turned into local data that legislators remember.
Conclusion
House Bill 1142 became law not by moving in a straight line but by surviving committee scheduling, markup, a fiscal note, and an appropriations negotiation that turned a statewide program into a regional pilot. Understanding these stages, and especially the committee and fiscal steps where most bills stop, allows DNP-prepared nurses to intervene where it matters.
References
Kangovi, S., Mitra, N., Grande, D., Long, J. A., & Asch, D. A. (2020). Evidence-based community health worker program addresses unmet social needs and generates positive return on investment. Health Affairs, 39(2), 207-213. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2019.00981
Kangovi, S., Mitra, N., Norton, L., Harte, R., Zhao, X., Carter, T., Grande, D., & Long, J. A. (2018). Effect of community health worker support on clinical outcomes of low-income patients across primary care facilities: A randomized clinical trial. JAMA Internal Medicine, 178(12), 1635-1643. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2018.4630
Longest, B. B., Jr. (2016). Health policymaking in the United States (6th ed.). Health Administration Press.
What the DNP870 Module 1 instructions ask for
The first module of Aspen's DNP870 typically asks you to trace a health bill through the legislative process, with attention to committee. Choose one bill, real or composite, and follow it stage by stage. Explain what happens at drafting, hearing, markup, fiscal review, the floor, the second chamber and the governor. Show where the bill could have died and why it did not. Explain the fiscal note and how it shaped the outcome. Use a policymaking source to name the stages accurately. Identify where nurses can influence the bill, with specific actions. Keep a composite state if you invent details, and make sure the vote counts, amendments and dollar figures stay consistent from stage to stage.
How this DNP870 Module 1 example is built
The introduction contrasts the straight textbook diagram with the stalls that happen in practice. The bill section explains House Bill 1142 and its basis in community health worker trials. Stage one covers drafting by the nonpartisan office after meetings with the nurses association and worker organizations. Stage two explains why committees are where most bills end and how the hearing was won. Stage three describes the managed care and timing amendments and the 9 to 4 vote. Stage four explains the fiscal note's first estimate, its rules on counting savings and the appropriations negotiation that produced a regional pilot. Stage five covers the floor vote of 71 to 27, the Senate and the governor. Five intervention points and a conclusion follow.
DNP870 Module 1 rubric: what earns full marks
Legislative process papers in DNP870 earn marks for accurate stages, a traceable example, attention to committee and fiscal review, and practical points of influence. This example earns credit by explaining why the bill nearly stalled at each stage rather than only that it advanced. Longest's sixth edition of Health Policymaking in the United States, from 2016, supplies the policy formulation stages. Kangovi and colleagues' 2018 trial and 2020 Health Affairs analysis of return on investment supply the evidence that made the bill fundable. The fiscal note section is where many papers are thin, and this one explains how scoring rules shaped the outcome. Five named intervention points turn the trace into a guide for nurse advocates.
DNP870 Module 1 help: mistakes that cost marks
Process papers often recite how a bill becomes law without an example. Follow one bill. Another common gap is skipping the fiscal note, which often decides health bills. Explain it. Students also treat committee as a formality; describe scheduling, hearings and markup. Name amendments and what each bought. Keep vote counts and figures consistent. Identify where nurses can act, with timing. Use a policymaking source for stage names. Keep the state composite if details are invented. Avoid overstating nurses' influence at the floor stage, where most votes are already settled. Finally, close with what you would do first if this bill were in your state next session, since the course builds on the same bill.
Write yours, or have the desk draft it
This paper is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Aspen University document. Read it for the moves, then write your own to the instructions in your classroom. If you want one built to your exact prompt and rubric, the first custom sample is free and arrives in 24 to 48 hours.
More DNP870 and DNP sample papers
- DNP870 Module 2: Legislation Versus Regulation Paper
- DNP870 Module 3: Health Policy Analysis Paper
- DNP870 Module 4: Policy Options Analysis
- DNP870 Module 5: Policy Stakeholder Map
- DNP870 Module 6: Professional Organization Advocacy Discussion
- DNP870 Module 7: Legislative Testimony
- DNP870 Module 8: Advocacy Plan
- DNP 851B Module 5: Answering the PICOT Question
- DNP 850B Module 7: Ethics, Human Subjects Training and Review
- DNP 825 Module 8: Informatics-Enabled Quality Improvement Proposal
- DNP855 Module 5: Authority and Responsibility Discussion
DNP870 Module 1 questions, answered
What does DNP870 Module 1 usually ask for?
The first module often asks you to trace how a health bill moves through the legislative process, especially committee, using a real or composite bill. Aspen does not publish module deliverables, so your classroom's instructions govern.
Why do so many bills die in committee?
Committee chairs control which bills receive hearings, and bills with costs face fiscal notes and appropriations review. Many bills are never scheduled for a hearing or cannot secure funding.
What is a fiscal note?
An estimate, prepared by the legislature's fiscal office, of a bill's cost or revenue effect. It often determines whether a bill with spending moves forward and can be influenced by data on offsetting savings.
Where can I find a free DNP870 Module 1 sample paper?
The full DNP870 Module 1 paper is above, tracing a state community health worker coverage bill from drafting through committee, fiscal note and appropriations.
Why did the bill in DNP870 Module 1 become a pilot?
Its first fiscal note priced statewide coverage at $14 million a year without counting savings, so appropriations narrowed it to a regional pilot with an evaluation.